A review by witcheep
A Tempest of Tea by Hafsah Faizal

adventurous emotional funny mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.5

I like the book a lot: the characters are amazing and the elements of the plot are adding up into an intriquing mystery. Even before reading the book I knew I'd want to have a deep dive into it; I've read Faizal's Sands of Arawiya duology before and enjoyed it so much I had to preorder this book.

The plot: a heist wrapped in secrets

Secrets are at the core of the book, the topic comes up repeatedly and often. As Arthie gathers her chosen group for the heist in the Athereum, every one of the five members seems to have their own secrets and hidden motives for their actions – and I loved speculating and later finding out about them! Even the premise of Arthie's business lies in her having secrets as her preferred currency:
To the public, Arthie Casimir dealt in tea. To those who paid attention, she dealt in blood too. But Flick had read every letter and document she had forged for the girl and knew the truth: Arthie Casimir dealt in secrets.

The characters have multiple sides to them, and they keep secrets from each other. This means their trust on each other is fragile at best, but still they work for the common goal together. While doing so, there are multiple potential romantic relationships developing in the group by the means of shameless flirting, attentive actions and even displays of jealousy. Perhaps it's a little overkill to have every member of the group have feelings for somone in the group, but I enjoyed it regardless.

A hinted destiny for the main character

The main character Arthie is depicted as a cunning criminal mastermind, but an underdog in the bigger picture. She holds her inner circle tight, but cares for them deeply and protects them fiercely. At times it feels like this is relayed to the reader more of as "told" rather than "shown", which makes it a little less easy to believe. Arthie is a loveable character, though, and her intelligence is also shown on the pages of the book. It seems that faith has a few surprises in hand for Arthie, both regarding love, career, and life in general.

I'm not sure whether or not Arthie is interested in love at all. She's quite determined to think that every relationship is transactional, and this will make accepting falling in love with anyone difficult. This brings even more interest into the budding infatuations in the book: will Arthie let herself fall in love?  There's a love arrow with Arthie as the main interest of two men (could be a love triangle if the men in question would show clear interest in each other) and her pondering whether she has feelings for them or not. 

"Seems your boss has taken a liking to me," Matteo said with a pride.
     Chester tilted his head, considering him with a fresh understanding on his way out. "Boss likes anyone with secrets."
     Arthie almost laughed at Matteo's pout. "He isn't wrong."

There's also interesting intertextuality in the book: Arthie's weapon, a gun called Calibore, bears striking resemblance to the legends of King Arthur and his sword Excalibur. Both these weapons were held in stone, and have a legend that the one who could draw them would become to rule. In A Tempest of Tea Arthie doesn't show interest in ruling over people, but who's to say that the Arthurian legend won't be foreshadowing and mean that Arthie will end up having to do it anyway?

"Why save the world when you can have tea?"

Oh, and let me just end the review by saying that the ending of the book will be a huge, dramatic cliffhanger that you cannot handle as is. Thankfully there is a bonus epilogue, and at least at the time of writing this review, it was quite easily found online with a quick search. You will need that bonus epilogue in hand right after finishing the book. The bonus epilogue will shed light on the identity of a certain character and bring some ease to the cliffhanger.

________________________________

I made dozens of annotations to the book while reading, and anjoyed speculating the plot while doing so. I also host a readalong for the book here: https://app.thestorygraph.com/readalongs/b85d9fd3-d2b1-4421-9559-7abbe0a34b71 You're welcome to come discuss the book with me in the readalong. I'd love to hear others' theories and opinions on the book!

Review written 31.3.2024
Expand filter menu Content Warnings