A review by momobookdiary
Fair Play by Louise Hegarty

3.0

Louise Hegarty’s Fair Play begins with an intriguing premise—a birthday celebration, a murder mystery party, and a group of friends navigating shifting relationships. Abigail and her brother Benjamin have always been close, but when the morning after the party arrives, Benjamin is found dead, and suddenly, reality takes an unexpected turn.

The novel starts off strong, shrouded in mystery and emotional depth. However, as the story transitions into a more traditional locked-room mystery—complete with an eminent detective, a butler, a gardener, and a housekeeper—the initial grip it had on me started to fade. While the book remains well-written and inventive, the shift in style and the introduction of additional characters made it feel less engaging for me personally.

That said, Fair Play is undoubtedly a creative and unique debut. It explores not just the mechanics of a murder mystery but also the hidden lives we think we know and the secrets buried beneath the surface of close relationships. For those who enjoy experimental takes on classic mystery structures, this book may prove to be a rewarding read.