A review by r_j_setser
The Wayward by Tabitha Caplinger

emotional reflective sad slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.5

"In the shelter of the evergreen forests, strangers had become soulmates."

The Wayward beautifully captures the emotions expected of a dystopian novel; faith amid hopelessness, treasuring the small joys amid oppression, and pushing through grief until you see triumph.

I enjoyed the characters, especially Wilder and Declan, and thought their marriage was encouraging to see in fiction. I feel like many times, book romances end in marriage and as readers, we rarely get to see the relationship struggles beyond the vows, so I appreciated that the majority of this book centered on a married couple rather than the dating phases.

"Perhaps the sadness helps us remain grateful for the joy."

That being said, without including spoilers, I would like to point out to potential readers that this book is not intended for the Young Adult (YA) audience. Is it appropriate? Absolutely. But the characters face very real-world (marriage) scenarios that many teens and young adults may find boring or unrelatable, because the romance isn't the thrill of the chase (as is common in most YA dystopian novels), but rather an established, healthy marriage. Would I be comfortable handing it to a YA reader? Yes; and I would even encourage YA readers to pick it up because of the display of healthy relationships and I believe that YA readers need to see more of that example in fiction, but I want to reiterate that the characters face some very mature topics that can make it difficult to read at times. Especially if you've gone through it. It took me a long time to get through this book because of the tragedy and sorrow that is so heavily laced into the story, that I just had to take a lot of breaks.

The plot is gripping and overall, I believe that it's exactly the story that the author wanted to tell and that the comforting messages during loss are accomplished exactly as the author intended. It's a beautiful book and I recommend it to readers who are seeking fiction with depth and faith amid heavy trials.

"Silence is underrated at times, but it can be good for the soul. Sometimes we just need another person to be in the room with us and it's enough."

I received this book from the author. All comments and opinions are entirely my own and this review is voluntary. 

Expand filter menu Content Warnings