Take a photo of a barcode or cover
mdistefano 's review for:
Woodswoman
by Anne LaBastille
On the surface, this book is enjoyable (hence the two-star rating instead of just one star). If you just want to sit back and read about a woman living her best life in the woods with her dog, this book deserves five stars. But if you want to actually get a sense of the Adirondack experience, this book isn't it.
Anne LaBastille rubbed me the wrong way in the first chapter (though I do admit to not being a huge fan of hers before I read the book). She's full of inconsistencies and hypocrisies: She also makes some questionable choices that she takes as personal attacks on her character even though they're her own fault, such as My main issue is that LaBastille tries to portray her cabin at Black Bear Lake as a utopia, glossing over the less-savory aspects that don't lend themselves to be funny stories to be written into books. I wanted to read something that was true, and this felt very cherry-picked (I do realize that she couldn't write about everything she experienced, but there were very few sections of the book that felt genuine to me). For example,
I found her thoughts on the year-round inhabitants of the region despicable.
However, a highlight of the book for me was
Long story short: if you're just looking for an easy read about wandering in the woods, this is a good choice. If you actually want to learn anything, read elsewhere. I could go on forever on the issues I have with Anne LaBastille.
Anne LaBastille rubbed me the wrong way in the first chapter (though I do admit to not being a huge fan of hers before I read the book). She's full of inconsistencies and hypocrisies:
Spoiler
telling us she built her cabin all by herself while also detailing all the help she got from local carpenters, and how she has no qualms about shooting a bear and using its pelt as a chair back but shies away from having beaver pelts in her home because her lake is full of beavers.Spoiler
when she has to move her cabin back an additional twelve feet because she didn't bother to read the terms of sale for her property, and had built her cabin too close to the lake.Spoiler
she mentions multiple times how perfect the lake water is and how it's so lovely that she can just cup her hands and be able to drink straight from the lake/river, though it isn't until towards the end of the book that she mentions the damage done to the Adirondack waterways by acid rain. It doesn't take a genius to know that if there's been acid rain in an area for any extended amount of time (like there has been in the Adirondacks since at least the 1960s!), you shouldn't be drinking the lake water.I found her thoughts on the year-round inhabitants of the region despicable.
Spoiler
LaBastille refers to cities and places outside the Adirondacks as more educated and cultured, and how it was a breath of fresh air for her to visit Washington, DC for a few months because of a job. Her view of Adirondack locals is judgemental and backwards, and she has very little respect for them; since she lived there year-round for many years, they deserved far better than to be referred to as less refined and educated than LaBastille just because she had a PhD from Cornell and did intermittent work in South America (which I do admit was important and interesting stuff).However, a highlight of the book for me was
Spoiler
when LaBastille refused to go to Alaska with her boyfriend Nick because she would have to leave the Adirondacks behind, possibly forever. Never leave everything you love behind just to be with a man. That was a good message from her.Long story short: if you're just looking for an easy read about wandering in the woods, this is a good choice. If you actually want to learn anything, read elsewhere. I could go on forever on the issues I have with Anne LaBastille.