Scan barcode
A review by katykelly
Tradition by Brendan Kiely
3.0
Private school privilege is challenged in a story of feminism and gender.
3.5 stars.
Two narrators take on the telling, of an attempted rape and the aftermath, how it affects both the victim and her friends as well as how the school and other students react.
Jules, from the very first time we meet her, shows us just what we are meant to feel about her - she's handing out 'safe sex' information to students on their first day at the prestigious Fullbrook. She's a 'rebel', she doesn't play by the rules but is worthy, smart and well-intentioned. Her male counterpart is Jamie. He's had to leave his previous public school for reasons undisclosed and managing to attend the private school with a hockey scholarship, and we soon see he doesn't fit in with the typical mindset of the young men who are students there.
I was curious as to where this was heading. Jules and Jamie both are outsiders to the traditions of the school, neither is willing to let things stand, and both are tested as events mean they have to choose between conforming and letting things lie, or standing up and making a stand, fighting back, being heard.
It's a tough one to 'grade', I enjoyed listening to this, the two narrators sounded adolescent enough and they made the pretty mature and intelligent pair sound authentic, but something didn't sit quite right. After considering, I think it was Jamie - he's an outsider, and has a past. It seems that if it wasn't for his own issues then he probably wouldn't notice the problems with Fullbrook. So is it only those outside of the system that would see the flaws?
Jules I liked from the start (and that's not to say I didn't like Jamie too). Her situation is a hard one - she ISN'T raped (it's not a graphic scene), but she is not prepared to keep quiet. When readers see what goes on in the school, it is obvious that something has to be done. But there was the flaw for me, even as I enjoyed it, the conclusion is less than spellbinding, it's a little deflating and I think I said to myself: "Is that it?"
I liked the topic and setting, the distasteful and lurid ideologies of the students and the main pair we are rooting for, but it could have been more.
The audio version is well-narrated by two readers covering Jules and Jamie, making them teenagers you care about. It was the right format for an audiobook, flitting between their points of view fairly sequentially and with lots of narrative thought and speech.
A popular topic at the moment, it unfortunately doesn't stand out as a genre leader, but does add a persepective of its unlikely setting.
With thanks to Nudge Books for providing a sample Audible copy.
3.5 stars.
Two narrators take on the telling, of an attempted rape and the aftermath, how it affects both the victim and her friends as well as how the school and other students react.
Jules, from the very first time we meet her, shows us just what we are meant to feel about her - she's handing out 'safe sex' information to students on their first day at the prestigious Fullbrook. She's a 'rebel', she doesn't play by the rules but is worthy, smart and well-intentioned. Her male counterpart is Jamie. He's had to leave his previous public school for reasons undisclosed and managing to attend the private school with a hockey scholarship, and we soon see he doesn't fit in with the typical mindset of the young men who are students there.
I was curious as to where this was heading. Jules and Jamie both are outsiders to the traditions of the school, neither is willing to let things stand, and both are tested as events mean they have to choose between conforming and letting things lie, or standing up and making a stand, fighting back, being heard.
It's a tough one to 'grade', I enjoyed listening to this, the two narrators sounded adolescent enough and they made the pretty mature and intelligent pair sound authentic, but something didn't sit quite right. After considering, I think it was Jamie - he's an outsider, and has a past. It seems that if it wasn't for his own issues then he probably wouldn't notice the problems with Fullbrook. So is it only those outside of the system that would see the flaws?
Jules I liked from the start (and that's not to say I didn't like Jamie too). Her situation is a hard one - she ISN'T raped (it's not a graphic scene), but she is not prepared to keep quiet. When readers see what goes on in the school, it is obvious that something has to be done. But there was the flaw for me, even as I enjoyed it, the conclusion is less than spellbinding, it's a little deflating and I think I said to myself: "Is that it?"
I liked the topic and setting, the distasteful and lurid ideologies of the students and the main pair we are rooting for, but it could have been more.
The audio version is well-narrated by two readers covering Jules and Jamie, making them teenagers you care about. It was the right format for an audiobook, flitting between their points of view fairly sequentially and with lots of narrative thought and speech.
A popular topic at the moment, it unfortunately doesn't stand out as a genre leader, but does add a persepective of its unlikely setting.
With thanks to Nudge Books for providing a sample Audible copy.