Scan barcode
A review by gracescanlon
Did You Hear About Kitty Karr? by Crystal Smith Paul
Did not finish book. Stopped at 7%.
Holy exposition, Batman!
I’ve checked the e-book out from the library three times now, but have never read past the first chapter. I admit defeat; I am DNF’ing this one at 7%.
Did You Hear About Kitty Karr? begins with the most tedious telling, with no showing that I can recall. The author seemed to feel it necessary to explain the backstory and current implications of every single action or spoken dialogue. This lack of skill had me rolling my eyes so far back into my head and so often that I worried they’d get stuck staring at the darkness of my eye sockets forever.
The concept intrigued me, so I tried — I really did. I couldn’t get past the first chapter, as the world-building was so weak I wanted to scream. Telling is necessary in storytelling, of course, but it shouldn’t completely dominate the story — at most, it should make up 30% of it, with the rest told via showing.
The biggest impact telling the story without showing had on me as a reader, though, was that I just. didn’t. care. about any of the characters, Elise least of all. She had the personality of a damp sponge — though to use the word “personality” in any sentence describing the character is generous. So, I didn’t care; I was annoyed by the clunky (at best) storytelling; and, worst of all, I was bored bored bored.
I value my own time, so I will not pick this up again.
I’ve checked the e-book out from the library three times now, but have never read past the first chapter. I admit defeat; I am DNF’ing this one at 7%.
Did You Hear About Kitty Karr? begins with the most tedious telling, with no showing that I can recall. The author seemed to feel it necessary to explain the backstory and current implications of every single action or spoken dialogue. This lack of skill had me rolling my eyes so far back into my head and so often that I worried they’d get stuck staring at the darkness of my eye sockets forever.
The concept intrigued me, so I tried — I really did. I couldn’t get past the first chapter, as the world-building was so weak I wanted to scream. Telling is necessary in storytelling, of course, but it shouldn’t completely dominate the story — at most, it should make up 30% of it, with the rest told via showing.
The biggest impact telling the story without showing had on me as a reader, though, was that I just. didn’t. care. about any of the characters, Elise least of all. She had the personality of a damp sponge — though to use the word “personality” in any sentence describing the character is generous. So, I didn’t care; I was annoyed by the clunky (at best) storytelling; and, worst of all, I was bored bored bored.
I value my own time, so I will not pick this up again.