You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
A review by akryku
A Wild Swan: And Other Tales by Michael Cunningham
1.0
I am not quite sure what's up with authors and re-writing fairy tales. Walker tried it with her [b:Feminist Fairy Tales|469261|Feminist Fairy Tales|Barbara G. Walker|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1347911936s/469261.jpg|689941] (they are terrible, please don't read them) and there are countless YA-Titles which include and re-work fairy tales and often produce a sappy love story filled with idiotic protagonists.
It is only natural that sometimes it seems to me that fairy tales are perceived as an easy target. "Look," (insert a random author here),"these are just tales for children, I am sure they are easy to write. I mean, how hard can it really be?" Of course, this often leads to another thing re-written fairy tales are often subjected to. "These are for kids? Let's make them daaaark and edgy and grrritty! Let's add sex, drugs and rock'n'roll!"
And that's basically what A Wild Swan: And Other Tales is. It is a darker re-write and it failed. Hard. One big gripe I have with dark re-tellings of fairy tales in general is that they are not really needed. The original versions and even still popular versions of fairy tales already deal with pretty heavy themes without needing help from other authors. The orignal Rapunzel was raped and pregnant, Andersen's tales are often very depressive and don't have happy ends and even the Gretel of today merrily kills the evil witch by burning her alive.
The edginess in A Wild Swan comes from various sources but the most prevalent theme is that marriage sucks. Always and in every way. The Giantess in "Jack and the Bean Stalk" only helps Jack because she wants to get back at her husband somehow, the married pair in "The Nutcracker" only comes together because she finds his missing leg attractive and the parents in "A Monkey's Paw" are lethargic and would rather be divorced today rather than tomorrow.
Also there is a lot of unneeded and frankly sometimes downright irrational sexual content. The witch of Hansel and Gretel is a former sex addict, Beauty from Beauty and the Beast fantasizes about being raped by the Beast (and in one instance by her father) and the big nonsensical twist is basically the implication that.
Rumpelstiltskin is a Nice Guy and gets pissy when his emotional manipulation fails and the princess marries the Asshole Prince. So to get back at her he tries to take her child and not, as the intro of the tale implies, because he wants a child just so badly.
There is also Cunningham's compulsion to describe everything in grisly detail which really doesn't mesh well with tales like "The Monkey's Paw", a story that works best with the fear of the unknown and untold.
There is also the fact that for example "The Nutcracker" isn't so much a re-telling of the original tale but a mess of a story with the occasional allusion to the original.
The only redeeming qualities of this book are the art and two stories that aren't offensive but merely boring. It fails one every other count. There are no morals, no character development and they don't add anything worthwhile. Not a single character as far as I can remember is portrayed as positive. It is just not good, I am sorry.
*Please note that I used the names of the original fairy tales in order to avoid confusion.
It is only natural that sometimes it seems to me that fairy tales are perceived as an easy target. "Look," (insert a random author here),"these are just tales for children, I am sure they are easy to write. I mean, how hard can it really be?" Of course, this often leads to another thing re-written fairy tales are often subjected to. "These are for kids? Let's make them daaaark and edgy and grrritty! Let's add sex, drugs and rock'n'roll!"
And that's basically what A Wild Swan: And Other Tales is. It is a darker re-write and it failed. Hard. One big gripe I have with dark re-tellings of fairy tales in general is that they are not really needed. The original versions and even still popular versions of fairy tales already deal with pretty heavy themes without needing help from other authors. The orignal Rapunzel was raped and pregnant, Andersen's tales are often very depressive and don't have happy ends and even the Gretel of today merrily kills the evil witch by burning her alive.
The edginess in A Wild Swan comes from various sources but the most prevalent theme is that marriage sucks. Always and in every way. The Giantess in "Jack and the Bean Stalk" only helps Jack because she wants to get back at her husband somehow, the married pair in "The Nutcracker" only comes together because she finds his missing leg attractive and the parents in "A Monkey's Paw" are lethargic and would rather be divorced today rather than tomorrow.
Also there is a lot of unneeded and frankly sometimes downright irrational sexual content. The witch of Hansel and Gretel is a former sex addict, Beauty from Beauty and the Beast fantasizes about being raped by the Beast (and in one instance by her father) and the big nonsensical twist is basically the implication that
Spoiler
human!Beast is going to sexually abuse her. Since the narrator has not a single positive thing to say about Beauty throughout the story this comes across as a twisted "Take that!" at BeautyRumpelstiltskin is a Nice Guy and gets pissy when his emotional manipulation fails and the princess marries the Asshole Prince. So to get back at her he tries to take her child and not, as the intro of the tale implies, because he wants a child just so badly.
There is also Cunningham's compulsion to describe everything in grisly detail which really doesn't mesh well with tales like "The Monkey's Paw", a story that works best with the fear of the unknown and untold.
There is also the fact that for example "The Nutcracker" isn't so much a re-telling of the original tale but a mess of a story with the occasional allusion to the original.
The only redeeming qualities of this book are the art and two stories that aren't offensive but merely boring. It fails one every other count. There are no morals, no character development and they don't add anything worthwhile. Not a single character as far as I can remember is portrayed as positive. It is just not good, I am sorry.
*Please note that I used the names of the original fairy tales in order to avoid confusion.