A review by booksnorkel
The Ruby in the Smoke by Philip Pullman

This book was stupid. It was sloppy and had a dumb ending. But murphyreads you sound like a fourth grader talking about a book they were forced to read, well guess what I DON'T CARE for those of you who like Pullman and think that this will be as good as the His Dark Materials series you are wrong and will be sad.