Scan barcode
A review by koistyfishy
The Love Hypothesis by Ali Hazelwood
emotional
funny
inspiring
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
3.5 Pumpkin Spice Stars ⭐️
Spicy Level: 🌶️/5
Spicy Level (With Adam Bonus Chapter): 🌶️🌶️/5
Hypothesis: Any book by Ali Hazelwood will start great but will end as a disappointment.
This is what you get when you couple a smart but stupid pathological liar and a grumpy scientist and say "Now Kiss". The Love Hypothesis was the second book I picked up by Ali Hazelwood and the one that everybody told me I should’ve read first.
It had the foundation to be perfect! Thinking back to my time in a university lab it was like I was running a perfect experiment. I was set up with excellent reagents, and superbly clean glassware (if I do say so myself) and everything appeared to be going well. But somewhere something turned, a temperature setting was wrong or the wrong solvent was used for the chromatography column. In the end, whilst the reaction did yield some results, the expected yield was significantly lower and utterly disappointing.
This is a single POV that follows Olive, she is a Biology Graduate Student and to persuade her best friend that it is okay for her to date her ex-boyfriend instead of having an adult conversation about thoughts and feelings she decides to lie to her friend and kisses Dr Adam Carlton. Then proceeds to deepen the lie by roping him into a scheme to pretend to be her boyfriend so that her best friend doesn’t feel bad. Some stuff about pancreatic cancer also adds to the plot...
Olive is what I would describe as the stupidest smart person I have ever encountered and is nothing but a pathological liar. As someone whose career is built on scientific fact and truth the ease at which the opposite can come out of her mouth is a little bit concerning. She is insecure and (like I am starting to believe all Ali Hazelwood's FMCs) - she is not like the "other girls". Because being a woman in STEM means that you have to be ditzy or strange or have some quirk or wear rainbow-coloured knee-high socks that make you seem "special". Because you can't just be a regular person who studies something in STEM like anybody else.
Poor poor POOOOOR Adam Carlton, the man who has clearly been in love with Olive since he first saw her. If felt like every time Olive and he would have a conversation she would insult is actions, behaviour and methods of teaching. She would talk based on other people's opinions - of what she has been told and would completely lambaste the poor traumatised man for having standards for his students in ONE OF THE MOST PRESTIGIOUS SCIENCE PROGRAMS IN THE WORLD... but no...being grumpy is a crime. I don't think for the majority of the book she had one nice thing to say to him and he was still besotted with her. I also wish I knew what he liked to eat because any mention of food was just how he didn't like it or how it tasted of feet...like besides broccoli what does this man enjoy besides Olive(s)....
Now don't get me wrong - I was enjoying this. The actual writing was so good in the start - I was eating it up, I loved the rom-com tropes thrown in (even if they were just added for the hook) up until... read if you don't care about spoilers(view spoiler)
The amount of lack of communication and lies made Olive seem childish and immature and her actions just irritated me beyond the enjoyment of the book I just wanted it to end so I didn't have to deal with what felt drawn out and unnecessary. It didn't help that the plot felt recycled from Love on the Brain (even though that one was probably recycled from this...).
Trope Summary:
▶ Woman in STEM Representation
▶ Fake Dating
▶ "She Falls First" but actually he did years ago
▶ One Bed
▶ Hates Everyone But Her
▶ Workplace/College Setting
▶ Age Gap
▶ Grumpy X Sunshine
Overall I don't know what to think of Ali Hazelwood - everyone loves her books but I just feel like for the second time in a row my hypothesis keeps being proven and I don't know if I have it in me to risk repeating another experiment with the same disappointed results.
Spicy Level: 🌶️/5
Spicy Level (With Adam Bonus Chapter): 🌶️🌶️/5
Hypothesis: Any book by Ali Hazelwood will start great but will end as a disappointment.
This is what you get when you couple a smart but stupid pathological liar and a grumpy scientist and say "Now Kiss". The Love Hypothesis was the second book I picked up by Ali Hazelwood and the one that everybody told me I should’ve read first.
It had the foundation to be perfect! Thinking back to my time in a university lab it was like I was running a perfect experiment. I was set up with excellent reagents, and superbly clean glassware (if I do say so myself) and everything appeared to be going well. But somewhere something turned, a temperature setting was wrong or the wrong solvent was used for the chromatography column. In the end, whilst the reaction did yield some results, the expected yield was significantly lower and utterly disappointing.
This is a single POV that follows Olive, she is a Biology Graduate Student and to persuade her best friend that it is okay for her to date her ex-boyfriend instead of having an adult conversation about thoughts and feelings she decides to lie to her friend and kisses Dr Adam Carlton. Then proceeds to deepen the lie by roping him into a scheme to pretend to be her boyfriend so that her best friend doesn’t feel bad. Some stuff about pancreatic cancer also adds to the plot...
Olive is what I would describe as the stupidest smart person I have ever encountered and is nothing but a pathological liar. As someone whose career is built on scientific fact and truth the ease at which the opposite can come out of her mouth is a little bit concerning. She is insecure and (like I am starting to believe all Ali Hazelwood's FMCs) - she is not like the "other girls". Because being a woman in STEM means that you have to be ditzy or strange or have some quirk or wear rainbow-coloured knee-high socks that make you seem "special". Because you can't just be a regular person who studies something in STEM like anybody else.
Poor poor POOOOOR Adam Carlton, the man who has clearly been in love with Olive since he first saw her. If felt like every time Olive and he would have a conversation she would insult is actions, behaviour and methods of teaching. She would talk based on other people's opinions - of what she has been told and would completely lambaste the poor traumatised man for having standards for his students in ONE OF THE MOST PRESTIGIOUS SCIENCE PROGRAMS IN THE WORLD... but no...being grumpy is a crime. I don't think for the majority of the book she had one nice thing to say to him and he was still besotted with her. I also wish I knew what he liked to eat because any mention of food was just how he didn't like it or how it tasted of feet...like besides broccoli what does this man enjoy besides Olive(s)....
Now don't get me wrong - I was enjoying this. The actual writing was so good in the start - I was eating it up, I loved the rom-com tropes thrown in (even if they were just added for the hook) up until... read if you don't care about spoilers(view spoiler)
The amount of lack of communication and lies made Olive seem childish and immature and her actions just irritated me beyond the enjoyment of the book I just wanted it to end so I didn't have to deal with what felt drawn out and unnecessary. It didn't help that the plot felt recycled from Love on the Brain (even though that one was probably recycled from this...).
Trope Summary:
▶ Woman in STEM Representation
▶ Fake Dating
▶ "She Falls First" but actually he did years ago
▶ One Bed
▶ Hates Everyone But Her
▶ Workplace/College Setting
▶ Age Gap
▶ Grumpy X Sunshine
Overall I don't know what to think of Ali Hazelwood - everyone loves her books but I just feel like for the second time in a row my hypothesis keeps being proven and I don't know if I have it in me to risk repeating another experiment with the same disappointed results.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Sexual harassment
Moderate: Cancer and Death of parent