Take a photo of a barcode or cover
domine 's review for:
Minor Detail
by Adania Shibli
"And the situation has been like this for such a long time that there aren’t many people alive today who remember little details about what life was like before all this."
I can never wrap my head around how human beings can grow so accustomed to living under oppression where no birdsong is ever heard without the thunderous sound of bombs in the background, where people weep over the loss of their loved ones, babies cry endlessly, screams echo through the streets, and so many other horrors I can’t even begin to imagine. And yet people still wake up, still eat, still hope—because what else is there to do? It’s haunting to think that survival itself becomes a daily act of resilience.
Minor Detail is divided into two parts. The first part tells the situation at the Eleventh Settlements in the Negev where army patrols moved through the southern hills near the Egyptian border. The story takes place a year after the ethnic cleansing and dispossession of Palestinian Arabs, known as the Nakba in 1948. The following year saw the Battle of Nirim that happened shortly after the end of the Second World War with an aim to expand the territory of Jewish settlements in the south. An armistice occurred during that period between the settlers and the Egyptian Army. It is in the aftermath of that war that the tragedy at the center of the story unfolds—a young Bedouin woman is killed by members of the settlement army. I can't help but to think that it was a good transition into the second part, where we follow a Palestinian researcher who stumbles upon an article about that very Bedouin woman. It was later revealed that the meaning behind the title Minor Detail actually refers to the detail in the article: the date of the incident that aligns exactly with the researcher’s birth date in twenty-five years later.
"The incident took place on a morning that would coincide, exactly a quarter of a century later, with the morning of my birth." and then, "It's an innate tendecy, one might say, toward a belief in the uniqueness of the self, toward regarding the life one leads so highly that one cannot but love life and everything about it."
The motives behind her research are clear to me, though I still feel there's something missing... something that would justify the lengths she goes to risking everything and even her life to conduct this research. She does mention that it’s a study of the geography and social topography of the area, which makes me wonder: was her interest in the Bedouin woman’s case driven purely by curiosity? I’m not entirely sure about that part. But through this book I learned about the divisions within the West Bank like how it’s split into Area A and Area B (which are more Palestinian-controlled) and Area C that is fully under Israeli civil and security control. Her research takes place in Area C, and that’s where the tension really builds. I still consider Minor Detail an important read, because I see books about Palestinian history as something I must engage with. It feels like the least I can do: to listen, to learn, and to carry their stories with me, even if only through the pages of a book.
I can never wrap my head around how human beings can grow so accustomed to living under oppression where no birdsong is ever heard without the thunderous sound of bombs in the background, where people weep over the loss of their loved ones, babies cry endlessly, screams echo through the streets, and so many other horrors I can’t even begin to imagine. And yet people still wake up, still eat, still hope—because what else is there to do? It’s haunting to think that survival itself becomes a daily act of resilience.
Minor Detail is divided into two parts. The first part tells the situation at the Eleventh Settlements in the Negev where army patrols moved through the southern hills near the Egyptian border. The story takes place a year after the ethnic cleansing and dispossession of Palestinian Arabs, known as the Nakba in 1948. The following year saw the Battle of Nirim that happened shortly after the end of the Second World War with an aim to expand the territory of Jewish settlements in the south. An armistice occurred during that period between the settlers and the Egyptian Army. It is in the aftermath of that war that the tragedy at the center of the story unfolds—a young Bedouin woman is killed by members of the settlement army. I can't help but to think that it was a good transition into the second part, where we follow a Palestinian researcher who stumbles upon an article about that very Bedouin woman. It was later revealed that the meaning behind the title Minor Detail actually refers to the detail in the article: the date of the incident that aligns exactly with the researcher’s birth date in twenty-five years later.
"The incident took place on a morning that would coincide, exactly a quarter of a century later, with the morning of my birth." and then, "It's an innate tendecy, one might say, toward a belief in the uniqueness of the self, toward regarding the life one leads so highly that one cannot but love life and everything about it."
The motives behind her research are clear to me, though I still feel there's something missing... something that would justify the lengths she goes to risking everything and even her life to conduct this research. She does mention that it’s a study of the geography and social topography of the area, which makes me wonder: was her interest in the Bedouin woman’s case driven purely by curiosity? I’m not entirely sure about that part. But through this book I learned about the divisions within the West Bank like how it’s split into Area A and Area B (which are more Palestinian-controlled) and Area C that is fully under Israeli civil and security control. Her research takes place in Area C, and that’s where the tension really builds. I still consider Minor Detail an important read, because I see books about Palestinian history as something I must engage with. It feels like the least I can do: to listen, to learn, and to carry their stories with me, even if only through the pages of a book.