Take a photo of a barcode or cover
penguin_emperor_of_the_north 's review for:
God Emperor of Dune
by Frank Herbert
On the plus side, this book is more focused than Children. On the downside that's a low bar to clear. Also, this is a lot of book for very little plot. I'd guess most of the appeal here is reading Leto's rambling . . . sorry, expounding on his views of government, religion, society et al. Though for me, that was rather painful to read so I just did not enjoy the threadbare plot interspersed around Leto's monologues.
Leto really reminded me of some people I've met who thought they were so much smarter that they couldn't be bothered to answer questions. Oh no, Leto's going to respond with vague statements and rhetorical questions to teach everyone a lesson; he can't be bothered to just give a clear answer or explanation. Then again, he's 3500 years old, maybe I should cut him some slack.
But besides Leto rambling, ope sorry, expounding, on his theories of life, the universe and everything not much happens. A few characters meet him for the first time and basically react to meeting him and learning his plan but that's pretty much it. There's just a ton of dialogue in here (most of it involving Leto rambling).
I start thinking about the series a whole now since I think I'll skip books 5 and 6 and there are some high level spoilers for this book and the previous below.
It is somewhat fascinating to see how the series evolved. Dune 1 is a space opera adventure with hints of a darkness to Paul's rise as the Fremen's mahdi to lead the jihad across the galaxy. Messiah makes the 'fear the charismatic chosen one' idea more explicit (while really focusing on the effects on Paul) and introduces more ideas like the Face Dancers and the Ixians (guess the Butlerian Jihad didn't really take). But then in Children the the Golden Path, genetic memory and gets introduced and in God Emperor we learn that humanity's survival is dependent on being subjugated by a prescient, immortal dictator for 3500 years so he can teach us a lesson and run a breeding program (how do we know that's true? the prescient, immortal dictator said so. If you can't trust him, who can you trust?)
Which leads to an interesting theme through the series where we learn to fear the ubermensch who'll set himself above us but that ultimately, an ubermensch dictator is needed to forcibly lead humanity on the one path that leads to survival. And that's a really cynical outlook, that warning against the ubermensch combined with the idea that people are so easily controlled that our only hope is a self-appointed, benevolent ubermensch to save us from ourselves (and literally breed the susceptibility to ubermenschen out of us). I respect that level of blunt cynicism but dang. Can't imagine actually viewing people like that.
However, I think there's an even deeper theme to Dune. See, the Butlerian Jihad to destroy thinking machines was done to break people's reliance on computers and machinery to do things that people could've done for themselves (which I sympathize with, especially every time I rely on spell check or use a calculator for a simple calculation).
But humanity follows that up with relying on Arrakis' spice melange monopoly, the Spacing Guild's travel monopoly and the Great House's monopoly on violence (not a true monopoly but effectively one considering shields effectively eliminate firearms and bring a warrior aristocracy back). And humanity being subject to all of these monopolies leaves them subject to the horrors of Paul and Leto's reigns when Paul consolidates all power in his own person.
So, that's the moral of the story. Practice self sufficiency, resist monopolies, take responsibility for your own self defense or else you'll be enslaved by a three thousand year old space worm and forced to take part in his breeding program.
You know, I started that 'deeper theme' section thinking I was going to crack a joke about how it's good to get away from your phones but not to get hooked on space drugs. I kind of like the conclusion I came to but seriously, don't do space drugs. That'll get you enslaved by space worms too.
Leto really reminded me of some people I've met who thought they were so much smarter that they couldn't be bothered to answer questions. Oh no, Leto's going to respond with vague statements and rhetorical questions to teach everyone a lesson; he can't be bothered to just give a clear answer or explanation. Then again, he's 3500 years old, maybe I should cut him some slack.
But besides Leto rambling, ope sorry, expounding, on his theories of life, the universe and everything not much happens. A few characters meet him for the first time and basically react to meeting him and learning his plan but that's pretty much it. There's just a ton of dialogue in here (most of it involving Leto rambling).
I start thinking about the series a whole now since I think I'll skip books 5 and 6 and there are some high level spoilers for this book and the previous below.
It is somewhat fascinating to see how the series evolved. Dune 1 is a space opera adventure with hints of a darkness to Paul's rise as the Fremen's mahdi to lead the jihad across the galaxy. Messiah makes the 'fear the charismatic chosen one' idea more explicit (while really focusing on the effects on Paul) and introduces more ideas like the Face Dancers and the Ixians (guess the Butlerian Jihad didn't really take). But then in Children the the Golden Path, genetic memory and
Spoiler
possessionWhich leads to an interesting theme through the series where we learn to fear the ubermensch who'll set himself above us but that ultimately, an ubermensch dictator is needed to forcibly lead humanity on the one path that leads to survival. And that's a really cynical outlook, that warning against the ubermensch combined with the idea that people are so easily controlled that our only hope is a self-appointed, benevolent ubermensch to save us from ourselves (and literally breed the susceptibility to ubermenschen out of us). I respect that level of blunt cynicism but dang. Can't imagine actually viewing people like that.
However, I think there's an even deeper theme to Dune. See, the Butlerian Jihad to destroy thinking machines was done to break people's reliance on computers and machinery to do things that people could've done for themselves (which I sympathize with, especially every time I rely on spell check or use a calculator for a simple calculation).
But humanity follows that up with relying on Arrakis' spice melange monopoly, the Spacing Guild's travel monopoly and the Great House's monopoly on violence (not a true monopoly but effectively one considering shields effectively eliminate firearms and bring a warrior aristocracy back). And humanity being subject to all of these monopolies leaves them subject to the horrors of Paul and Leto's reigns when Paul consolidates all power in his own person.
So, that's the moral of the story. Practice self sufficiency, resist monopolies, take responsibility for your own self defense or else you'll be enslaved by a three thousand year old space worm and forced to take part in his breeding program.
You know, I started that 'deeper theme' section thinking I was going to crack a joke about how it's good to get away from your phones but not to get hooked on space drugs. I kind of like the conclusion I came to but seriously, don't do space drugs. That'll get you enslaved by space worms too.