A review by kjackmi
Death Comes to Pemberley by P.D. James

2.0

I'm really surprised at Dame James. Perhaps she merely wanted to try her hand at writing like Austen. At that she was fairly successful. But as a mystery this is very weak, nothing James's usual procedurals. No detecting is done, which may come as a relief to those picturing Darcy lifting fingerprints or questioning witnesses. I had many quibbles with this book: an extended opening reciting to us the plot of Pride and Prejudice (really? Who would read this book that doesn't know that story?); the mystery is lame and then--horror of horrors-- she presumes to explain Darcy's conduct in P & P! For one, pretty well explained by Austen, and secondly, how presumptuous to put words in the characters mouth relating to the previous book! Ain't your story OR your character, leave in alone! Also, almost no Elizabeth so what is the point. No sparkle, no wit, no shining dialogue. Ugh. Here's hoping this esteemed author goes back to her own creation-- Dalgliesh.