A review by caw34
Fire and Ice by Shannon Hale

3.0

3.5

Each book is relatively engaging, but I don't really get the overall "goal": collect the talismans and then what? Also each book has been the same: need to find animal, struggle to find animal, struggle to find talisman, struggle against Shane et al for talisman, either keep talisman or lose it dramatically/painfully to Shane. Repeat.