Scan barcode
A review by btwnprintedpgs
Song of Silver, Flame Like Night by Amélie Wen Zhao
adventurous
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
I really wanted to DNF this story about 35% in - the beginning was exciting and dark and full of action, and then we hit this absolute lull of information dumping and vague travel through the forest. Then we get to a school and suddenly we're bombarded by names and people and things that are all new to me. It was a lot, especially since I'm a Canadianized CBC who knows nothing about these legends and gods. It was hard to digest everything, even though I really wanted to.
That being said, I'm glad I stuck it out - there's a lull for about 15% of the story, but it picks up again and then it's non-stop go-go-go from there. Then the gods, the mystery, and everything start to fall into place. I feel like if we had more showing instead of telling from the start I would've adjusted better, but as they go through all these things and discover everything that's going on, all that lore starts to make more sense and is explained better. These things also helped to unravel who these characters are - Zen, who's desperate to be good and protect the people he loves, even if he has to make bad deals for that to happen; Lan, who's headstrong and hates rules, trying to find a way to save the world without losing herself in the process; along with the masters and disciples of the school.
I loved the lyrical writing - it's very flowery and aligns with the style of storytelling I'm used to from these stories. Though, at times, it was a bit odd *queue the Star Wars reference, or Bible reference, whichever is to your taste* but I loved that it contributed to a lot of the world building and painted us a picture of the characters so well in that moment.
One thing I did feel was that this mimicked her original trilogy a bit - girl with untapped power meets a man who can help her somehow, an escape from an army, and a group coming together to train and change the regime - and I couldn't help seeing the parallels as I read. I think Amelie's writing has improved a lot since her debut, but I couldn't help hear an echo of it as I read Song.
All in all, I enjoyed this story and I'm very curious about what book 2 holds for us now that the world and lore has been well established!
TW: death of a parent, sexual assault, violence, death, blood, injury detail, war, torture, suicide, grief; mentions loss of family in war, imprisonment, mutilation
That being said, I'm glad I stuck it out - there's a lull for about 15% of the story, but it picks up again and then it's non-stop go-go-go from there. Then the gods, the mystery, and everything start to fall into place. I feel like if we had more showing instead of telling from the start I would've adjusted better, but as they go through all these things and discover everything that's going on, all that lore starts to make more sense and is explained better. These things also helped to unravel who these characters are - Zen, who's desperate to be good and protect the people he loves, even if he has to make bad deals for that to happen; Lan, who's headstrong and hates rules, trying to find a way to save the world without losing herself in the process; along with the masters and disciples of the school.
I loved the lyrical writing - it's very flowery and aligns with the style of storytelling I'm used to from these stories. Though, at times, it was a bit odd *queue the Star Wars reference, or Bible reference, whichever is to your taste* but I loved that it contributed to a lot of the world building and painted us a picture of the characters so well in that moment.
One thing I did feel was that this mimicked her original trilogy a bit - girl with untapped power meets a man who can help her somehow, an escape from an army, and a group coming together to train and change the regime - and I couldn't help seeing the parallels as I read. I think Amelie's writing has improved a lot since her debut, but I couldn't help hear an echo of it as I read Song.
All in all, I enjoyed this story and I'm very curious about what book 2 holds for us now that the world and lore has been well established!
TW: death of a parent, sexual assault, violence, death, blood, injury detail, war, torture, suicide, grief; mentions loss of family in war, imprisonment, mutilation
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Suicide, Violence, Blood, and Grief
Moderate: Sexual assault, Death of parent, and War