5.0

A triumph. I don't know the texts (Cather, Poe, Hemingway) or whether she's fair to them, but that's almost not the point. It's more like reading [a: James Baldwin|10427|James Baldwin|https://d.gr-assets.com/authors/1343346341p2/10427.jpg], if he had New Critic chops, and were using them to destroy the basis of New Criticism.