A review by irishmbk
Promise Not to Tell by Jennifer McMahon

4.0

This one scared the pants off me, but despite the nightmares it was incredibly hard to put down and I finished it very quickly. This is the the story of the potato girl who is murdered and then turned into a rural legend after her death. Then someone else is murdered thirty years later in the exact same way and a small Vermont town is shook to its core and dirty little secrets from the past come tumbling out. Relationships, bullying, and questioning yourself in this well written, scary novel. Great book but shiver the potato girl haunted me to the very finish.