uma_booksbagsburgers's profile picture

uma_booksbagsburgers 's review for:

DC Comics Novels - Batman: The Killing Joke by Gary Phillips, Christa Faust
4.0

(A huge thanks to Bloomsbury India for sending me this book in exchange for an honest review.)

I'm going to start off by saying that I have not read the comic, The Killing Joke. So my review won't be comparing the two but rather just be talking about the novelization by itself. I found this book to be quite dark and gritty. There's physical and mental abuse and quite a few things that can make people feel queasy.

That being said, the author has done an immensely good job of bringing together multiple plot lines and binding them together into one story. This is not just the story of Batman and Joker. This is the story of a girl who moonlights as a superhero and revels in the freedom, it's the story of the girl who wants to escape from life under a drug dealer, it's the story of a man who lost his family, it's the story of a cop trying to play the hero, it's the story of a cop who loves his daughter, it's the story of a boy who worked for the wrong man, it's the story of how one bad day reduces the sanest man alive to lunacy... or does it?

For me the character that stood out most was Barbara Gordon. Her character arc was the most dark and complex but i can't say much about giving away any spoilers. This book sets up the arena for the future DC novelizations from Titan Books. Introducing a certain character the way the author did at the end was so genius and unexpected.

I enjoyed the conversations between Bruce and Alfred. Not all the conversations added much to the story but they sure added a lot to the characters' personalities. Growing up with Nolan's version of Alfred, this Alfred seemed quite different to me and it was intriguing to learn about him. I also enjoyed the conversations between the patients of Arkham asylum and their conversations with the doctors there. It was interesting seeing how some criminal masterminds justified their crimes in their own twisted manner.

Although I was underwhelmed by Harleen Quinzel whenever she appeared in this novel. Hopefully her character will be built more in Mad Love because I'm really looking forward to reading that! I also missed seeing enough of Batman. He's probably considered the main character but he wasn't around as much and I wished we'd seen more of him throughout the book.

To sum up, this novelization of The Killing Joke is dark and gritty with a well written and brought together plot but I'd have liked to see more development when it comes to some characters.