A review by libraryforspooky
The Five-Star Weekend by Elin Hilderbrand

4.0

This book fulfills Massachusetts in a self reading challenge of a book taking place in every US State or territory (2/56).

Elin Hilderbrand's "The Five-Star Weekend" is a delightful blend of heartfelt drama, rich character exploration, and the quintessential charm of Nantucket. The novel centers around Hollis Shaw, a successful food blogger who finds herself navigating the complexities of grief, friendship, and self-discovery after the tragic death of her husband, Matthew.

The story kicks off with Hollis's seemingly perfect life shattering after an argument with Matthew ends in his untimely death. This event exposes the fissures in her life, from her strained marriage to her complicated relationship with her daughter, Caroline. In an effort to reclaim some semblance of control and connection, Hollis decides to host a "Five-Star Weekend" on Nantucket, inviting friends from different stages of her life: her teenage years, her twenties, her thirties, and her midlife.

Each of Hollis's friends brings their own set of challenges and unresolved issues to the weekend. Tatum, her childhood friend, finds herself awkwardly reunited with Hollis's first love, Jack Finigan, arranged by her own husband. Dru-Ann, the elitist sports agent from UNC Chapel Hill, is grappling with career-threatening controversy. Brooke, from Hollis's thirties, is dealing with her husband's infidelity yet again. Finally, there's Gigi, a mysterious stranger who connected with Hollis through her blog, carrying secrets of her own.

Hilderbrand excels in creating a vivid and immersive setting, with Nantucket almost serving as a character in its own right. The detailed descriptions of the island's shops, restaurants, and landscapes add depth and atmosphere to the narrative, making readers feel as if they are part of the exclusive weekend getaway.

The novel's strength lies in its character development and the dynamics between the women. Each character is well-drawn and relatable, with their personal struggles and growth arcs woven seamlessly into the overarching story. Hollis's journey from grief to a newfound understanding of herself and her relationships is particularly compelling. The interactions between the women, filled with tension, humor, and moments of profound connection, highlight the complexities of long-term friendships and the impact they have on our lives.

However, the novel is not without its flaws. Some readers might find the plot predictable and the resolution of certain conflicts a bit too tidy. The emphasis on luxury and brand-name dropping can feel excessive at times, potentially detracting from the emotional depth of the story. Despite these minor issues, the book's charm and the authenticity of its characters' experiences make it a satisfying read.

"The Five-Star Weekend" by Elin Hilderbrand is an engaging and heartwarming tale of friendship, loss, and self-discovery. It captures the essence of what it means to reconnect with one's past while forging a new path forward. With its rich setting and well-developed characters, it is a perfect beach read that leaves readers reflecting on their own relationships and the people who shape their lives. A solid four-star rating reflects its ability to entertain and resonate, making it a noteworthy addition to Hilderbrand's impressive body of work.