cynthiasreadinglist 's review for:

The Fire Never Goes Out: A Memoir in Pictures by ND Stevenson

2.0

---

It was just okay. I know Noelle is a Capricorn and this reads exactly like something a Cap would write...like just enough to keep you curious but walled up/ protected to keep up the pretenses. I know this because I'm also a Capricorn LOL. Idk, I just wish it were clear that it's like her Tumblr archives compiled in a book. I would have known what to expect. There wasn't present day reflection and I felt like I had to work really hard to not learn much at all. Some aspects were incredibly relatable and tender, but I read a memoir because I want insight and a deeper/detailed view of someone's life not pieces intentionally guarded to make you feel like you're getting access to secrets when you're really not. I also would have appreciated introspection about personal identities and privilege. For example, she writes about the 2016 election and the Pulse shooting, but what do these events mean and how do they resonate with her as a white, middle class, cis-woman, who is also queer. Especially since the victims of Pulse were predominantly people of color, the impact is just not the same. Like come on, let's dig deeper and be honest about race dynamics and social inequities. I wanted and expected more. A small note: some of the text was incredibly hard to read and I'm mildly irked about it.

Could be worth reading if you're a big fan; many of the comics are lovely. Can't say I personally recommend, but I can see the appeal.