A review by mikaylay
The Boxcar Librarian: A Novel by Brianna Labuskes

adventurous emotional informative mysterious medium-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? A mix
• Strong character development? Yes
• Loveable characters? Yes
• Diverse cast of characters? Yes
• Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

 Thank you to Netgalley, Harpercollins, and Brianna Labuskes for an E-ARC copy of the book in exchange for an honest review. 
 

The characters, setting, and prose, woven together with an intricately crafted plot, transformed this novel into a vivid cinematic experience unfurling before my eyes as I read. The characters leaped to life, drawing me into their tale and inviting me to accompany them on their unique journeys. The trio of female protagonists—Alice, Millie, and Colette—formed a remarkable alliance, each possessing distinct personalities, traits, and styles, yet united by their shared values of loyalty and love for those who nurtured their growth. They resonate with individuals facing daily tribulations and striving to rise above them, as well as with the books that connect souls beyond their expectations and beliefs, much like the bond shared by these three inspiring women.

The supporting characters played a pivotal role in the narrative, offering readers a window into the diverse lifestyles, occupations, perspectives, and realities of the 1930s and 1940s. Each character was well-developed, unique, and enchantingly magical, while also embodying the relatable and realistic aspects of humanity, allowing readers to not only connect with them but also feel as if they were stepping into their shoes. The book's atmosphere and settings were vividly portrayed, realistic, and meticulously crafted. The writing seamlessly blended realism with a touch of magic, making it feel as though I wasn't merely reading about the characters, but standing alongside them in their world. I experienced their dialogues, witnessed their struggles, and observed the formation of bonds that were truly extraordinary.

The plot began a bit slowly but captured my full attention during the last 200 pages, refusing to let go. The narrative was constructed in a manner that tricked me into thinking I could foresee the outcome, yet the author surprised me with beautifully executed plot twists that had me exclaiming, “wait a minute, what?” and “I love the connection that was just made.” This book masterfully intertwines reality and fiction, delving into themes of life, love, mystery, and dreams during the 1930s and 1940s. I thoroughly enjoyed discovering the various projects from that era, particularly how the author wove them into the narrative, from the Writer’s Project to the library initiative.

I appreciated the inclusion of the author's journal at the end, detailing her journey in uncovering the true story behind the novel, the individuals who aided her, the sources she relied upon, and her overall passion and experience in researching it. The Boxcar Librarian by Brianna Labuskes is more than just a historical fiction tale centered around a boxcar librarian; it explores the myriad ways in which people forge connections through struggles, hardships, grief, shared interests, hope, love, kindness, and even solitude. The novel beautifully underscores the power of literature and community. I wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone seeking an immersive reading experience, as well as those interested in understanding how literature connects us to both familiar faces and strangers.