A review by scottishben
Before Watchmen: Minutemen/Silk Spectre by Darwyn Cooke

2.0

Really well done showing artists and writers really making the most out of Alan Moore's world but in this volume at least it fails to do anything with the world to make it feel like a complete and satisfying work in its own right.

Now where near as bad as the star wars prequels - there is plenty of creativity and class to be found here just ultimately Watchmen told all the story that needed to be told with this world and characters.

There is enough quality here that I will probably go on and read some of the other volumes but most people will get more out of just rereading Watchmen one more time.