Scan barcode
A review by thexwalrus
The Broken Girls by Simone St. James
dark
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
simone st. james is an absolutely incredible writer, and all of the things i adored from the sun down motel are just as present here in the broken girls.
the characters in this story are just as loveable and lovely as i expected, and the big cornerstone in this is friendship - sonia, roberta, katie, and cece are brought together by circumstance and end up loving each other as much as one human can love another person. they become a family, and the love between them runs so deep and makes each revelation ache in the best way. while it is a genuinely tense and spooky horror/thriller, it also feels like a love story about enduring friendship.
fiona and her father, malcom, are fiery, passionate characters - while malcom is only tertiary, he brings so much life to every part of the story he touches. fiona's perspective makes each of the people she meets more vibrant than they are to begin with - which is pretty damn vibrant, because st. james is a master at writing great characters. even characters i initially mistrusted end up being ones i opened my heart to - except for that one particular character i won't name because of spoilers. but if you read it, you'll know who i mean.
despite being, in essence, a story about five main characters, this ends up feeling like a visit to a small town where everyone knows everyone and everyone's pleased to see you; it captures the small town new england feel beautifully, and the way it's written feels like a raw, wet day in late autumn in vermont. basically, what i'm saying is it's perfect, and i loved every bit of it. absolutely read this.
the characters in this story are just as loveable and lovely as i expected, and the big cornerstone in this is friendship - sonia, roberta, katie, and cece are brought together by circumstance and end up loving each other as much as one human can love another person. they become a family, and the love between them runs so deep and makes each revelation ache in the best way. while it is a genuinely tense and spooky horror/thriller, it also feels like a love story about enduring friendship.
fiona and her father, malcom, are fiery, passionate characters - while malcom is only tertiary, he brings so much life to every part of the story he touches. fiona's perspective makes each of the people she meets more vibrant than they are to begin with - which is pretty damn vibrant, because st. james is a master at writing great characters. even characters i initially mistrusted end up being ones i opened my heart to - except for that one particular character i won't name because of spoilers. but if you read it, you'll know who i mean.
despite being, in essence, a story about five main characters, this ends up feeling like a visit to a small town where everyone knows everyone and everyone's pleased to see you; it captures the small town new england feel beautifully, and the way it's written feels like a raw, wet day in late autumn in vermont. basically, what i'm saying is it's perfect, and i loved every bit of it. absolutely read this.
Content Warnings
Minor: War, Child abuse, Antisemitism, Rape, and Suicide attempt
there are descriptions of a Ravensbrück, a concentration camp, and mentions of the torture women went through there, though none are so detailed i would consider them graphic.