A review by alaina_reads_and_wanders
The Duke and I by Julia Quinn

lighthearted slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.75

Like many people, I came here after the Netflix show, hoping for a little light-hearted entertainment. I rarely say this, but the show is way better in a lot of ways. The chemistry between the characters is more believable, their romance doesn't feel as rushed, and in general the characters are much more likable. (Plus, I think adding discussions of race and classism makes the entire series much more interesting and engaging than the book.) 

I strongly disliked the so-called-romance between the two characters in this book. Daphne's blatant manipulation of Simon for her own gain was hard for me to read -- it's extremely disturbing. I enjoy reading a dark romance from time to time, but this is not intended to be dark, so that's... concerning. I realize what was needed to move the plot along, but -- just no.

Beyond that, there was too much "fluff" in this book -- not much romance -- but somehow not enough deep character development either. It really didn't suit my character, plot, or romance needs at all. 

I've heard the other books in the series are better, but I don't know that I'm motivated to try them any time soon. Stay tuned... 
Expand filter menu Content Warnings