A review by readingpicnic
All Things Seen and Unseen: A Novel by R. J. McDaniel

dark emotional mysterious
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes

4.25

I received a free digital ARC of this book from the publisher.
I would say that this book is horror in the same way that The Haunting of Hill House is horror in that it is mainly psychological and deals a lot with trauma. A lot of the story's horror comes from the main character experiencing paranoia and anxiety due to being gaslit by an emotionally and physically abusive partner for years to the point that they feel that they’re crazy, struggling with mental illness and s*icidal thoughts, being chronically ill, losing touch with most of their friends, having no familial support, and almost becoming houseless. There was also horror in the sense that Alex is a queer and trans person of color surrounded by white people who wish them ill-will and harm in the village that they move nearby to, which was especially disturbing with the men who would follow them on the road and taunt them. I appreciated the portrayal of the main character’s struggle with their gender and how confusing it all is–from my understanding, the main character identified as nonbinary at one point and got top surgery before socially detransitioning after being invalidated by their abusive ex who said he would only view them as a girl. Towards the end of the story, as the main character is enveloped into a small trans group of friends and gets a transmasc love interest, they slowly start to become comfortable enough to identify as trans again and come back out of the closet. I loved how the pronouns switched throughout the story as the main character tried to figure themself out, and I thought it was extremely well done. 
I also thought that the main character’s anxiety was portrayed so well, and I have so many of the same overthinking anxious thoughts as them, which was nice to see represented. Overall, I loved Alex’s character, and they felt so real to me. Their humor was great, their thought processes and actions made sense to me, and I overall loved reading from their point of view. They reminded me a little bit of Mae from the game Night in the Woods with how they think and talk, which I enjoyed. I genuinely cared for Alex as a character and wanted the best for them-I was invested!
I do think that I got a little confused as to what was happening at certain points in the story, such as when Alex goes up the elevator, and the whole storm scene in general, but I also feel like that was the intention since the main character was so disoriented during that scene? I was also often confused about why Amara would get upset with Alex, especially for wanting them to pull over to let the truck driven by racist white men pass when they were in danger. I wish there had been some resolution to the dog killer subplot since that felt unresolved. It also felt like the story was building up to Amara not being who they said they were for a while with Alex’s suspicions of him and nobody having heard of him, but I’m glad that he ended up being someone that cared for Alex when they had no other support. I kind of wish more of the story took place in the creepy mansion they were housesitting because there was so much setting detailed there and so much anticipation built up with the security cameras in the creepy basement, the voice system to activate the lights, the shadow of a person at the door of the mansion in the security cameras, the security codes for everything, and the elevator they weren’t allowed to use, but very little of the plot actually happened there, which makes sense because it was so inaccessible, which is its own kind of horror for a disabled person. I did like the ending with Alex getting a mobility device that works for them, as well as living with their old friend group of queer and trans people because I think that they deserved and needed to have that support system.
Expand filter menu Content Warnings