Scan barcode
A review by katykelly
A Girl Like That by Tanaz Bhathena
4.0
Insightful look at teenage issues in Saudi Arabia - not so different to those anywhere else.
In setting this in a country we know mainly from news stories and other media, you have expectations of what you're going to get, who you're going to meet. But straightaway, we find ourselves in a Sunset Boulevard-esque opener, with two dead teenagers talking, after their car crash. The (religious) police believe they understand the 'type' of girl who would have been in a car with a boy, and what had happened. But Zarin and Porus don't fit their stereotype...
We are then taken back to Zarin's life leading up to the car crash. An orphan, she has spent her life quietly (or not so quietly) defying her uncle and aunt, dating boys, being her own person, despite the religious restrictions of her country. And Porus is the boy who's long been in love with her.
While this takes many directions that aren't much of a surprise, the fact that this is set in a country that restricts women makes what is a conventional enough story rather different. And it does give a new perspective to the treatment of women, making me consider other stories and situations in which females have had similar issues to contend with.
I enjoyed the multiple narrations, with both leads voicing, but also more minor characters bringing their own take on Zarin. The Audible narrators were well chosen for their age though I found the female reader much clearer than the male, who I had to keep turning the volume up to understand as well.
It felt universal in theme - the same issues crop up for adolescents wherever they live - but with a setting that I've not read about before, so I liked picturing this rather dangerous country and imagining what it must be like there.
The unfamiliar setting was what kept my attention, it will be a good choice to recommend to teenage readers who who be interested in other countries and moral systems.
With thanks to Nudge Book for providing a sample Audible copy for review purposes.
In setting this in a country we know mainly from news stories and other media, you have expectations of what you're going to get, who you're going to meet. But straightaway, we find ourselves in a Sunset Boulevard-esque opener, with two dead teenagers talking, after their car crash. The (religious) police believe they understand the 'type' of girl who would have been in a car with a boy, and what had happened. But Zarin and Porus don't fit their stereotype...
We are then taken back to Zarin's life leading up to the car crash. An orphan, she has spent her life quietly (or not so quietly) defying her uncle and aunt, dating boys, being her own person, despite the religious restrictions of her country. And Porus is the boy who's long been in love with her.
While this takes many directions that aren't much of a surprise, the fact that this is set in a country that restricts women makes what is a conventional enough story rather different. And it does give a new perspective to the treatment of women, making me consider other stories and situations in which females have had similar issues to contend with.
I enjoyed the multiple narrations, with both leads voicing, but also more minor characters bringing their own take on Zarin. The Audible narrators were well chosen for their age though I found the female reader much clearer than the male, who I had to keep turning the volume up to understand as well.
It felt universal in theme - the same issues crop up for adolescents wherever they live - but with a setting that I've not read about before, so I liked picturing this rather dangerous country and imagining what it must be like there.
The unfamiliar setting was what kept my attention, it will be a good choice to recommend to teenage readers who who be interested in other countries and moral systems.
With thanks to Nudge Book for providing a sample Audible copy for review purposes.