Scan barcode
A review by kris_mccracken
The Blood Dimmed Tide by Rennie Airth
3.0
With "The Blood Dimmed Tide", Rennie Airth delivers a historical mystery that, despite its intrigue, occasionally trips over its own ambitions. The second instalment of the John Madden series is billed as "A John Madden Mystery," but Madden's role here is more of a passive observer than a proactive sleuth, leaving readers with a curious sense of disconnect. Our once-gritty detective has abandoned his Scotland Yard badge in favour of country life, trading in clues and investigations for family and tranquillity.
When Madden does appear, he's less the complex anti-hero and more a paragon of virtue, the quintessential father, husband, and gentleman. This characterisation, while undeniably noble, robs him of depth. His spotless portrayal leaves little room for flaws, impulses, or moments of inner conflict, those humanising details that typically draw readers into a character's world. The result is a protagonist who feels more like an archetype than a person, leaving the story, despite its dark allure, feeling slightly emotionally hollow.
Similarly, Airth's antagonist emerges late in the game, more a grim spectre than a fleshed-out villain. Despite a half-hearted biographical sketch in the epilogue, the reader never glimpses the inner psyche or descent into depravity that might make him more unsettling. He becomes, rather disappointingly, a mere plot device to drive the story to its violent conclusion. It's a shame, as a more nuanced exploration of his motives could have lent the novel a deeper, more unnerving resonance.
Airth's prose is smooth and polished, weaving an evocative portrayal of 1930s England. Yet, a troubling gender dynamic emerges: Madden's wife, an ostensibly important figure in his life, becomes little more than a well-meaning but meddling distraction, relegated to the sidelines while Madden's male allies rally to his cause. This disparity reinforces certain stereotypes, giving the novel an unintentional but undeniable whiff of antiquated ideals.
For all its shortcomings, The Blood Dimmed Tide remains an enjoyable, if slightly unbalanced, journey into a world of mystery and morality. It's not a book that will redefine the genre, but for those seeking an atmospheric historical mystery, it delivers enough intrigue to satisfy. So, while it might not be Madden's finest hour, it's still worth a read.
⭐ ⭐ ⭐
When Madden does appear, he's less the complex anti-hero and more a paragon of virtue, the quintessential father, husband, and gentleman. This characterisation, while undeniably noble, robs him of depth. His spotless portrayal leaves little room for flaws, impulses, or moments of inner conflict, those humanising details that typically draw readers into a character's world. The result is a protagonist who feels more like an archetype than a person, leaving the story, despite its dark allure, feeling slightly emotionally hollow.
Similarly, Airth's antagonist emerges late in the game, more a grim spectre than a fleshed-out villain. Despite a half-hearted biographical sketch in the epilogue, the reader never glimpses the inner psyche or descent into depravity that might make him more unsettling. He becomes, rather disappointingly, a mere plot device to drive the story to its violent conclusion. It's a shame, as a more nuanced exploration of his motives could have lent the novel a deeper, more unnerving resonance.
Airth's prose is smooth and polished, weaving an evocative portrayal of 1930s England. Yet, a troubling gender dynamic emerges: Madden's wife, an ostensibly important figure in his life, becomes little more than a well-meaning but meddling distraction, relegated to the sidelines while Madden's male allies rally to his cause. This disparity reinforces certain stereotypes, giving the novel an unintentional but undeniable whiff of antiquated ideals.
For all its shortcomings, The Blood Dimmed Tide remains an enjoyable, if slightly unbalanced, journey into a world of mystery and morality. It's not a book that will redefine the genre, but for those seeking an atmospheric historical mystery, it delivers enough intrigue to satisfy. So, while it might not be Madden's finest hour, it's still worth a read.
⭐ ⭐ ⭐