Scan barcode
A review by redhdlibrarian
Shadow Scale by Rachel Hartman
3.0
I would have given this book 5 stars if the ending did not read like a hippy tripping on acid. I read 500 pages of excellently written dialog and plot for it all to accumulate to an ending that took less than 20 pages! I was assuming the author was going to turn these books into a trilogy.
The ending happened so fast and was written so oddly. Seraphina sounded as if she was tripping on acid witnessing all the "love in the world". I am not saying it should have ended differently or been written differently, I am just trying to say it took a completely different tone than the rest of the book.
I congratulate the author on ending the book in a typical, "girl gets guy way". She introduced a gay relationship into the mix and really tried to push our limits on what a healthy relationship is. However, I am not sure how a threesome relationship is going to play out or will be what the readers want. I would have much preferred Seraphina ending up with Kiggs and Glisselda finding love herself. Glisselda doesn't find love in the end And this is something I think the author could have expelled upon as well instead of giving it a glance over.
Same goes with the end of the war. You built up to it for 500 pages and ended it in 1 page! The technicalities of how Seraphina escaped her mind and showed her light are also too short.
I really wish this was turned into a trilogy. There is way too much left unexplained at then end of the book. I won't be the only one turned away because of unanswered relationships, abandoned characters and abruptness.
The ending happened so fast and was written so oddly. Seraphina sounded as if she was tripping on acid witnessing all the "love in the world". I am not saying it should have ended differently or been written differently, I am just trying to say it took a completely different tone than the rest of the book.
I congratulate the author on ending the book in a typical, "girl gets guy way". She introduced a gay relationship into the mix and really tried to push our limits on what a healthy relationship is. However, I am not sure how a threesome relationship is going to play out or will be what the readers want. I would have much preferred Seraphina ending up with Kiggs and Glisselda finding love herself. Glisselda doesn't find love in the end And this is something I think the author could have expelled upon as well instead of giving it a glance over.
Same goes with the end of the war. You built up to it for 500 pages and ended it in 1 page! The technicalities of how Seraphina escaped her mind and showed her light are also too short.
I really wish this was turned into a trilogy. There is way too much left unexplained at then end of the book. I won't be the only one turned away because of unanswered relationships, abandoned characters and abruptness.