A review by fischers_reads
Her Favorite Jack-O-Lantern by Rebecca Rennick

slow-paced

3.5

I LOVE FMC’s like Sally!! She is so quarky and fun but everyone thinks she so weird. Jack moves in Nextdoor to her super gothic house and is super intrigued by her. They knew who each other in high school but she wasn’t in his friend circle. Their interactions were so fun and I giggled more times than I could count. I had just finished a horror novella so this book was so welcomed. Jack is a sweetheart and although Sally had a crush on him in high school he definitely fell hard for her super fast now. He embraces her weirdness and loves her for her and it’s super cute. The fact that everyone in town couldn’t believe they were together was mind blowing. I wasn’t a huge fan of the spice. At times it felt very cringy and I found myself skimming over those parts. It was a cute fall read.