Scan barcode
A review by roaming_enn
Minor Detail by Adania Shibli
challenging
dark
sad
fast-paced
4.0
This book was written in two parts: third person from the POV of the Israeli officer that ends up raping a Palestinian girl in 1949, a year after the Nakba; and first person from the POV of a young Palestinian woman who learns about the girl's rape and murder in 1949 some fifty years or so later.
Every character is unnamed. The first part is from the POV of the Israeli soldier because nobody has ever learned about the girl's experience from her herself. The unnamed soldier is on patrol in the desert with his squad (I'm sure I'm not using these terms correctly). He receives an animal bite one night, and the bite swells up until he is in a lot of pain and barely able to move. This humanizes him and I felt sorry for him for a bit...until I read the rape scene. So of course I was glad he was in pain and I wished pain upon him for the rest of his days.
The second part is from the POV of the Palestinian young woman in present-day West Bank. She is transfixed by the story of the girl's fate because of one minor detail: the fact that it happened exactly 25 years before her birth. So she sets out on a perilous journey to find out more about this girl. Borders are a big part of her narrative; she feels compelled to cross borders when she sees them, and she can't always tell when she's gone too far. And this fact may prove fatal to her, especially given how dangerous it is to be Palestinian in a world ruled by Israel.
This was a poignant story, parallel lives, one moving from beyond the grave to affect the other's.
Every character is unnamed. The first part is from the POV of the Israeli soldier because nobody has ever learned about the girl's experience from her herself. The unnamed soldier is on patrol in the desert with his squad (I'm sure I'm not using these terms correctly). He receives an animal bite one night, and the bite swells up until he is in a lot of pain and barely able to move. This humanizes him and I felt sorry for him for a bit...until I read the rape scene. So of course I was glad he was in pain and I wished pain upon him for the rest of his days.
The second part is from the POV of the Palestinian young woman in present-day West Bank. She is transfixed by the story of the girl's fate because of one minor detail: the fact that it happened exactly 25 years before her birth. So she sets out on a perilous journey to find out more about this girl. Borders are a big part of her narrative; she feels compelled to cross borders when she sees them, and she can't always tell when she's gone too far. And this fact may prove fatal to her, especially given how dangerous it is to be Palestinian in a world ruled by Israel.
This was a poignant story, parallel lives, one moving from beyond the grave to affect the other's.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Rape and Murder