Scan barcode
A review by linesiunderline
The Comeback by E.L. Shen
challenging
emotional
inspiring
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Shen’s debut is a winning Middle Grade title in all kinds of ways. I can imagine pressing it into the hands of many young readers.
First off, the writing style is clear, direct, and has a down-to-earth tone that I think many kids will find real and accessible. This is not a poetic kind of Middle Grade reading experience, which I think makes this book better placed to have a broader audience than some books for this age group. Maxine sounds like a real kid. Her range of emotions and her way of dealing with the challenges she faces feel true to life.
It’s also nice to see a book about a hardworking kid pursuing her passion and not have the storyline be that she is some kind of dazzling super talent, or that she needs to achieve her Olympic dreams for all of the sacrifice to be worthwhile. I think kids will relate to Maxine’s dreams and also hopefully internalize a message that is important and worthy.
Speaking of important messages, the aspect of the novel where Maxine is faced with racism and racist microaggressions is really well done. Shen brings this topic centre stage and explores it thoughtfully. The way that Maxine holds onto the inspiration provided by her Asian figure skating idols shines in strong contrast to the painful experiences she has at school. Her parents’ support through these hardships is also conveyed sensitively.
This title is a fine example of realistic fiction, for kids who love sports, and stories about friendship and finding your inner strength.
First off, the writing style is clear, direct, and has a down-to-earth tone that I think many kids will find real and accessible. This is not a poetic kind of Middle Grade reading experience, which I think makes this book better placed to have a broader audience than some books for this age group. Maxine sounds like a real kid. Her range of emotions and her way of dealing with the challenges she faces feel true to life.
It’s also nice to see a book about a hardworking kid pursuing her passion and not have the storyline be that she is some kind of dazzling super talent, or that she needs to achieve her Olympic dreams for all of the sacrifice to be worthwhile. I think kids will relate to Maxine’s dreams and also hopefully internalize a message that is important and worthy.
Speaking of important messages, the aspect of the novel where Maxine is faced with racism and racist microaggressions is really well done. Shen brings this topic centre stage and explores it thoughtfully. The way that Maxine holds onto the inspiration provided by her Asian figure skating idols shines in strong contrast to the painful experiences she has at school. Her parents’ support through these hardships is also conveyed sensitively.
This title is a fine example of realistic fiction, for kids who love sports, and stories about friendship and finding your inner strength.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Bullying, Racial slurs, and Racism