Scan barcode
A review by bleadenreads
Of Women and Salt by Gabriela Garcia
emotional
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
Plot: 5 generations of Cuban women face civil wars, violence, revolutions, racism, family secrets, motherhood, sacrifices and addiction.
Review: I really wanted to love this book and was fully invested in the book that was sold to me by the blurb...
The novel really needed to be longer and fleshed out as the main premises of the book were not fully developed. I think Jeanette and Gloria were the only fully developed characters, I wanted more from Cecilia, Dolores, Carmen, Elena and Maydelis. However the end of Jeanette's storyline, I thought, was a shock and I almost thought I had missed a passage. The overall ending and link with Ana was good, but I wanted more closure from the others. Also, the book that is passed down through generations is merely that and had less significance/impact on the characters than I expected. I think the inscription, "We are force", ironically, could have lent more force to the characters and their decisions. The women had a lot of strength and secrets, facing continuous adversity and experiencing little joy and happiness.
I thought the passages following Gloria and her daughter Ana, and their experiences of being an immigrant and victim of ICE policies were heartbreaking and written with great sensitivity and power. However, I think this could have had more impact if they had been related somehow to the main women, rather than slightly interlinked.
I did think this was in parts well written and a fascinating insight into the US-Cuban immigrant culture and history.
Maybe the blurb shouldn't have placed so much emphasis on the 5 generations/family tree (especially as some are just briefly mentioned) and inherited book part, as the book was so much more than that 🤷♀️ The incessant violence faced by these women and their resilience, was not empowering, but an almost depressing reminder of the inherent patriarchal violence that women in Cuba (and their descendants in US) have faced for generations.
There are a LOT of trigger warnings in this book - domestic abuse, graphic violence, sexual assault and chronic drug addiction.
Review: I really wanted to love this book and was fully invested in the book that was sold to me by the blurb...
The novel really needed to be longer and fleshed out as the main premises of the book were not fully developed. I think Jeanette and Gloria were the only fully developed characters, I wanted more from Cecilia, Dolores, Carmen, Elena and Maydelis. However the end of Jeanette's storyline, I thought, was a shock and I almost thought I had missed a passage. The overall ending and link with Ana was good, but I wanted more closure from the others. Also, the book that is passed down through generations is merely that and had less significance/impact on the characters than I expected. I think the inscription, "We are force", ironically, could have lent more force to the characters and their decisions. The women had a lot of strength and secrets, facing continuous adversity and experiencing little joy and happiness.
I thought the passages following Gloria and her daughter Ana, and their experiences of being an immigrant and victim of ICE policies were heartbreaking and written with great sensitivity and power. However, I think this could have had more impact if they had been related somehow to the main women, rather than slightly interlinked.
I did think this was in parts well written and a fascinating insight into the US-Cuban immigrant culture and history.
Maybe the blurb shouldn't have placed so much emphasis on the 5 generations/family tree (especially as some are just briefly mentioned) and inherited book part, as the book was so much more than that 🤷♀️ The incessant violence faced by these women and their resilience, was not empowering, but an almost depressing reminder of the inherent patriarchal violence that women in Cuba (and their descendants in US) have faced for generations.
There are a LOT of trigger warnings in this book - domestic abuse, graphic violence, sexual assault and chronic drug addiction.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Sexual violence, Violence, Mental illness, Drug abuse, Drug use, and Death of parent