Scan barcode
A review by nataliesboooks
An Amish Heirloom: A Legacy of Love, the Cedar Chest, the Treasured Book, the Midwife's Dream by Kathleen Fuller, Beth Wiseman, Amy Clipston
3.0
A Legacy of Love (Amy Clipston) - 4 stars
Amy’s novella was clearly the best. It was a cute story about a second chance at love, and I really enjoyed the cameos from the Amish homestead series.
The Cedar Chest (Beth Wiseman) - 1.5 stars
I feel like Beth Wiseman might not be for me. Her stories tend to be fairly depressing and this one was no different. Both the flashback story and the story in the present were depressing. It was weird because while the story was super dark, it seemed like the conflict was resolved too easily.
The Treasured Book (Kathleen Fuller) - 3 stars
This one was cute. I haven’t read many stories about a non Amish person becoming Amish, so that added an interesting dimension to the plot.
The Midwife’s Dream (Kelly Irvin) - 1.5 stars
The story didn’t “gel” with me. I didn’t like the romance at all - it was very sudden and I didn’t get a sense of the great love he had for her. The plotline about the abandoned baby seemed borrowed from the Canadian West series by Janette Oke.
Amy’s novella was clearly the best. It was a cute story about a second chance at love, and I really enjoyed the cameos from the Amish homestead series.
The Cedar Chest (Beth Wiseman) - 1.5 stars
I feel like Beth Wiseman might not be for me. Her stories tend to be fairly depressing and this one was no different. Both the flashback story and the story in the present were depressing. It was weird because while the story was super dark, it seemed like the conflict was resolved too easily.
The Treasured Book (Kathleen Fuller) - 3 stars
This one was cute. I haven’t read many stories about a non Amish person becoming Amish, so that added an interesting dimension to the plot.
The Midwife’s Dream (Kelly Irvin) - 1.5 stars
The story didn’t “gel” with me. I didn’t like the romance at all - it was very sudden and I didn’t get a sense of the great love he had for her. The plotline about the abandoned baby seemed borrowed from the Canadian West series by Janette Oke.