Scan barcode
A review by ibeforem
A Study in Scarlet Women by Sherry Thomas
challenging
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
This series is a re-imagining of Sherlock Holmes where Sherlock is really a young woman named Charlotte Holmes.
Charlotte is the daughter of a well-off family, and as such she is expected to do one thing - marry. But she has no interest in marrying, she'd much rather go to university and become the headmistress of a school and make enough money to support herself with no husband in sight. After her father breaks a promise to send her to school, Charlotte exacts her revenge by making herself unmarriageable in the eyes of society and then running away to London, certain she will be able to find a job and make enough money to send herself to school. But along the way, she is posing as the mysterious Sherlock Holmes, sending letters to the local authorities to try to help solve a series of deaths that threaten to ensnare her sister at home.
I enjoyed this story, though I found the construction clunky at times. I felt we were just thrown into the Sherlock thing, and I felt like it had been happening for a while before we are brought in on the secret. I also thought the revelation at the end was very much out of left field. There is no indication ahead of time that that was where the story was headed, or if there was, I missed it. I did enjoy the slow introduction of people to match up with the names/roles we know from the classic Sherlock canon.
Overall I thought the story laid a promising foundation for the series. I know there was a lot she needed to accomplish in this book, and now that all that backstory is out of the way maybe the next one will move a little more smoothly.
Charlotte is the daughter of a well-off family, and as such she is expected to do one thing - marry. But she has no interest in marrying, she'd much rather go to university and become the headmistress of a school and make enough money to support herself with no husband in sight. After her father breaks a promise to send her to school, Charlotte exacts her revenge by making herself unmarriageable in the eyes of society and then running away to London, certain she will be able to find a job and make enough money to send herself to school. But along the way, she is posing as the mysterious Sherlock Holmes, sending letters to the local authorities to try to help solve a series of deaths that threaten to ensnare her sister at home.
I enjoyed this story, though I found the construction clunky at times. I felt we were just thrown into the Sherlock thing, and I felt like it had been happening for a while before we are brought in on the secret. I also thought the revelation at the end was very much out of left field. There is no indication ahead of time that that was where the story was headed, or if there was, I missed it. I did enjoy the slow introduction of people to match up with the names/roles we know from the classic Sherlock canon.
Overall I thought the story laid a promising foundation for the series. I know there was a lot she needed to accomplish in this book, and now that all that backstory is out of the way maybe the next one will move a little more smoothly.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Death
Minor: Pedophilia