Scan barcode
A review by erebus53
The Luminaries by Susan Dennard
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
funny
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
A youth fiction adventure with a little romance? that falls into the same sort of category as Hunger Games, Divergent, and Twilight, I didn't know whether I should cringe or laugh my way through this book. When her father turns out to be a traitor to the community, Winnie Wednesday's family are ostracised from the Luminary society of Hemlock Falls, a dreary town on the edge of a haunted forest full of spirits and monsters. Seven clans (named for the days of the week) are tasked with protecting the mortal world from Nightmares that are spawned in the Forest. This Clandestine group lives in a town where the sun seldom shines, and the children of the Hunter community are trained at a school that teaches them monster lore and battle tactics.
Winnie is just turning 16, and that qualifies to enter the trials to become a Hunter. She's not as hot with a bow as Katniss, but she does hide in trees, and has a lot of luck. There are two mystery monsters in the story. As Winnie struggles to survive in a monster ridden forest she encounters a strange presence that appears to warp reality and kill monsters. She also encounters a werewolf that she seems to think wants to kill her, but that seems to the reader is trying to rescue her... (not even going to give points for anyone trying to guess who that is - if it's not the obvious candidate in this story, then this is the reddest herring that ever swam). Nobody seems to take Winnie seriously when she tries to tell people that there is an unknown Whisperer monster out there, and that it is deadly and capable of crossing the wards that should keep the monsters contained within the Forest. I find it frustrating that this leans so hard into the "adults don't listen to kids" trope.
The town is getting paranoid about this werewolf, and its existence in the town, for the first time in 17 years, has the whole community motivated to start blood testing everyone to see if they are IT. It seems that these werewolves can't turn a human by biting them... so maybe there is some other way that one gets to be a werewolf.. like.. maybe they are born that way ... ? I guess we find that out in the next book too.(oh come on! is it a coincidence that the one 17yr old character in the story is also an orphan being raised by his aunt?... that all the testing starts at the school, but that this character has a habit of being chronically truant?) .
The Houses are a trope that are pretty common to this genre; it's been done by everything from Harry Potter to Children of Blood and Bone. The stereotypes in this one are underpinned by clan animals and sayings, but the characters themselves don't seem to have much of those guiding principles to them. It is really cool that the clans are contributed to from different parts of the world. This means that the cast of characters is fairly diverse, when it comes to skin and hair at least. There is at least one gay couple, and that is normalised. I don't know that there is much actual impact that these various differences contribute to the story, but it's better than everyone being painted as cis-het-white-folk.
There are a couple of puzzles in the story, as we find out that Winnie's father has raised her playing word games and puzzles, so they have secret codes that they share. When Winnie stumbles onto things left behind by her father, 4 years after his disappearance, we have the start of clues to a mystery... but that's stuff to be covered by future books.
I guess my issue is that this is a pretty derivative story and feels paint by numbers. The bad boy is in a band, and that's a little bit of a departure from the norm.. and be plays bass.. so he's not some flashy lead guitarist or anything.. but the semi-intimate one-on-one combat training feels like Divergent all over again. I might follow it up with future reads, but I'm not feeling much drive to do so.
Winnie is just turning 16, and that qualifies to enter the trials to become a Hunter. She's not as hot with a bow as Katniss, but she does hide in trees, and has a lot of luck. There are two mystery monsters in the story. As Winnie struggles to survive in a monster ridden forest she encounters a strange presence that appears to warp reality and kill monsters. She also encounters a werewolf that she seems to think wants to kill her, but that seems to the reader is trying to rescue her... (not even going to give points for anyone trying to guess who that is - if it's not the obvious candidate in this story, then this is the reddest herring that ever swam). Nobody seems to take Winnie seriously when she tries to tell people that there is an unknown Whisperer monster out there, and that it is deadly and capable of crossing the wards that should keep the monsters contained within the Forest. I find it frustrating that this leans so hard into the "adults don't listen to kids" trope.
The town is getting paranoid about this werewolf, and its existence in the town, for the first time in 17 years, has the whole community motivated to start blood testing everyone to see if they are IT. It seems that these werewolves can't turn a human by biting them... so maybe there is some other way that one gets to be a werewolf.. like.. maybe they are born that way ... ? I guess we find that out in the next book too.
The Houses are a trope that are pretty common to this genre; it's been done by everything from Harry Potter to Children of Blood and Bone. The stereotypes in this one are underpinned by clan animals and sayings, but the characters themselves don't seem to have much of those guiding principles to them. It is really cool that the clans are contributed to from different parts of the world. This means that the cast of characters is fairly diverse, when it comes to skin and hair at least. There is at least one gay couple, and that is normalised. I don't know that there is much actual impact that these various differences contribute to the story, but it's better than everyone being painted as cis-het-white-folk.
There are a couple of puzzles in the story, as we find out that Winnie's father has raised her playing word games and puzzles, so they have secret codes that they share. When Winnie stumbles onto things left behind by her father, 4 years after his disappearance, we have the start of clues to a mystery... but that's stuff to be covered by future books.
I guess my issue is that this is a pretty derivative story and feels paint by numbers. The bad boy is in a band, and that's a little bit of a departure from the norm.. and be plays bass.. so he's not some flashy lead guitarist or anything.. but the semi-intimate one-on-one combat training feels like Divergent all over again. I might follow it up with future reads, but I'm not feeling much drive to do so.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Grief, Blood, Bullying, Panic attacks/disorders, and Violence
Moderate: Child death