marieintheraw's profile picture

marieintheraw 's review for:

Why We Broke Up by Daniel Handler
2.0

What I've noticed is that people tend to feel one of two ways about this book; they either really love it or really hate it. I found myself to be in a middle grounds of sorts.
I did like how Daniel Handler built a world for this story.
Spoiler all the movies in the book are basically created for Min.
Unfortunately, I felt Min should have been...angrier with Ed in her letter?
Spoiler if I got cheated on and I decided to write a "why we broke up" letter...it'd be a lot angrier than hers was.
Ed was a jerk the entire time; the tone for how he was as a character was set within the first two items.
Spoiler he showed late on first date with a lame excuse? really?

I feel like I wanted more from this, but it felt slow and fell flat in some parts.