You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
mtwilsonwrites 's review for:
Ringer
by Lauren Oliver
Ringer is the second, and final, book in Lauren Oliver’s Replica duology. You can read my review of the first book here. Before reading, I wondered why it was called Ringer, and having finished I was still none the wiser. It seemed like they decided it should start with an ‘R’ and plucked a random word out the dictionary. So I looked it up, and a ringer is someone or something that looks like something else. Essentially another word to describe a replica. Interestingly, while a replica is exactly the same, a ringer seems to mean that they look very alike but are not exactly the same. This seems rather fitting, since Ringer explores the question of whether the replicas are ‘human’ and whether they can be distinguished from one another. So it’s actually a well thought out choice for a title.
For those not familiar with the series, Ringer (like Replica) includes the stories of Gemma and Lyra, with the book formatted as two separate halves that has to be ‘flipped’. They can be read one half after the other, either way around, or in alternating chapters. When I read the first book, I read Lyra’s story first then Gemma’s, whereas this time I read Gemma’s story first and then Lyra’s.
Unfortunately I found Gemma’s half a little boring, so it didn’t do a good job of drawing me into the story. I felt that not much happened and Gemma was put very much in the position of a reactive character rather than an active character. Things were happening to her, rather than her having any agency, which meant it didn’t feel like there was much drive in the plot.
I found Lyra’s half much more engaging. More happened and Lyra had a goal she was aiming for, so I felt more invested in her story than Gemma’s. It was really interesting seeing how Lyra’s view of the world is so limited due to being kept in Haven, and how she misinterprets people and situations because of the way she has been kept away from society.
Lauren Oliver has an almost poetic way of writing. She describes things in metaphor a lot, and the way she writes it, I understood everything she was describing. The way she writes her descriptions feels very immersive.
I liked the way the book explores questions of humanity and how we identify ourselves based on how others have identified us. To get the full meaning of the book, you really do have to read both halves, so you can’t appreciate the book’s overall effect and message until you’ve finished reading. I had much more appreciation for the complex story and concept Oliver explored after I’d finished the book than while I was actually reading it.
If you haven’t read it yet, I would consider reading it in alternating chapters. The main reason I didn’t read it that way was because I couldn’t be bothered with the faff of flipping the book over. However, I think it might make the story less slow to read it that way.
I only gave Ringer 3 stars, as I gave Replica 4 stars, and enjoyed the first book much more. There was more driving the first book, more tension and more to hold my interest. It is still an interesting concept though, and I’m glad I read the series.
For those not familiar with the series, Ringer (like Replica) includes the stories of Gemma and Lyra, with the book formatted as two separate halves that has to be ‘flipped’. They can be read one half after the other, either way around, or in alternating chapters. When I read the first book, I read Lyra’s story first then Gemma’s, whereas this time I read Gemma’s story first and then Lyra’s.
Unfortunately I found Gemma’s half a little boring, so it didn’t do a good job of drawing me into the story. I felt that not much happened and Gemma was put very much in the position of a reactive character rather than an active character. Things were happening to her, rather than her having any agency, which meant it didn’t feel like there was much drive in the plot.
I found Lyra’s half much more engaging. More happened and Lyra had a goal she was aiming for, so I felt more invested in her story than Gemma’s. It was really interesting seeing how Lyra’s view of the world is so limited due to being kept in Haven, and how she misinterprets people and situations because of the way she has been kept away from society.
Lauren Oliver has an almost poetic way of writing. She describes things in metaphor a lot, and the way she writes it, I understood everything she was describing. The way she writes her descriptions feels very immersive.
I liked the way the book explores questions of humanity and how we identify ourselves based on how others have identified us. To get the full meaning of the book, you really do have to read both halves, so you can’t appreciate the book’s overall effect and message until you’ve finished reading. I had much more appreciation for the complex story and concept Oliver explored after I’d finished the book than while I was actually reading it.
If you haven’t read it yet, I would consider reading it in alternating chapters. The main reason I didn’t read it that way was because I couldn’t be bothered with the faff of flipping the book over. However, I think it might make the story less slow to read it that way.
I only gave Ringer 3 stars, as I gave Replica 4 stars, and enjoyed the first book much more. There was more driving the first book, more tension and more to hold my interest. It is still an interesting concept though, and I’m glad I read the series.