theknightswhosaybook 's review for:

Manga Classics: Jane Eyre by Crystal S. Chan, Charlotte Brontë
4.0

I am so bad at writing reviews of classics. It's like the moment a bunch of other, more important people decide "yep, this is a Good Book, this is a Classic Work of Literature™", my brain goes "well, I'm out."

But, after trying hard to scrounge up some Opinions on Jane Eyre, here they are:
— The writing is nice! I know it's what makes the book hard to get through for some people, but I did enjoy it (mostly, at least. The good thing about superfluous writing is that it's, you know, superfluous. If you get tired of it, you can usually skip a couple of paragraphs without missing anything. Which I did occasionally.)
— I don't, technically, like Rochester, but because I loved the writing all the declarations of love were beautiful anyway. If you'd told me I would feel this way before I started reading it I probably wouldn't have believed you.
— I noticed Jane's explanation about how she's always on the extreme: either completely defiant, or completely obedient. But I didn't actually expect to see so much of the latter, given how much the introduction to this edition waxed poetic about Jane's defiant nature. I really get that little note about how Jane does appear weirdly subservient at times now. It's like, hon, St. John's evil. Stop doing whatever he wants??