tptimmons 's review for:

The Mothman Prophecies by John A. Keel
3.0

Such unforgettable, fascinating, but also frustrating book. First, it needed some major revision, I think, since too much of it reverts to an anecdote dump around Keel’s-worth-hearing commentary on “the phenomenon.” Second, Keel needed some sort of “selection principle” to make him decide which anecdotes were worth sharing.