A review by elissaoj
A Holly Jolly Ever After by Julie Murphy, Sierra Simone

emotional funny hopeful lighthearted

4.25

I love Christmas Notch and want to love every book in that universe! And I did love the parts of this book that are set there but the whole pregnancy story driving them apart was annoying. Also, if she’s been wanting to be pregnant for so long, I don’t think she’d make those choices. Winnie’s family storyline didn’t feel resolved and Kallum’s fears and anxieties didn’t feel properly addressed. Like wouldn’t he have hurts and concerns to address and air out with how Winnie treated him? IDK, the torn apart only to come back stronger trope didn’t seem fully ironed out. 

I’m ready for the Teddy Fletcher story and would really like to know who is going to fall in love with Isaac and where Addison’s story is going. More Christmas Notch and all these great characters!!!
Expand filter menu Content Warnings