Scan barcode
A review by librarycutie
A Fragile Enchantment by Allison Saft
inspiring
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
A Fragile Enchantment is a Bridgerton inspired romantic fantasy set in Regency England about a magical dressmaker commissioned to tailor a royal wedding. This sounded so promising and I was so excited for this book, but it unfortunately disappointed me.
firstly, the characters. to be blunt, I didn't like them. they were so boring and childish and didn't have any favorable qualities. I liked the side characters more, Sofie and Rosa specifically. if Sofie wasn't married to Jack, I would've loved to see their romance, but I could not stand him. Niamh was okay, I wanted to know more about her silver hair and the backstory more, we barely know her. I feel like all we got to know was Kit. Kit was tolerable at most, he was grumpy and had a rough past from the death of his mother and his upbringing with his father and his lack of parental guidance... but the only time I liked him was when he was around Niamh. even then, it was mediocre at best. he barely showed affection and when he did acted as if it was the hardest thing ever. just.... red flag, and not the good kind.
secondly, the story and magic. this is where I was confused a lot. their magic wasn't entirely explained in depth, so It puzzled me but I ended up giving up trying to understand. I just know Niamh can sew emotions or magic into clothes and Kit has flower power basically. the plot was boring and confusing, its all about a scandal sheet bringing down the Royals because of their racism towards Machlish (aka Irish). the author tried to make it political and important but it just didn't play out very well, the instant and boring romance took priority in the story.
"Is this a dream?"
"I don't know. Let me kiss you util dawn, and I suppose we'll find out."
lastly, there is one scene where the romance gets more PG-13 and had me a bit shocked considering this is supposed to be YA, I would be upset if my kids at 12 or 13 were reading this and found out there's a detailed sex scene on page. YA should stay closed door, it for literal kids under 17!
**thank you Netgalley for an arc
firstly, the characters. to be blunt, I didn't like them. they were so boring and childish and didn't have any favorable qualities. I liked the side characters more, Sofie and Rosa specifically. if Sofie wasn't married to Jack, I would've loved to see their romance, but I could not stand him. Niamh was okay, I wanted to know more about her silver hair and the backstory more, we barely know her. I feel like all we got to know was Kit. Kit was tolerable at most, he was grumpy and had a rough past from the death of his mother and his upbringing with his father and his lack of parental guidance... but the only time I liked him was when he was around Niamh. even then, it was mediocre at best. he barely showed affection and when he did acted as if it was the hardest thing ever. just.... red flag, and not the good kind.
secondly, the story and magic. this is where I was confused a lot. their magic wasn't entirely explained in depth, so It puzzled me but I ended up giving up trying to understand. I just know Niamh can sew emotions or magic into clothes and Kit has flower power basically. the plot was boring and confusing, its all about a scandal sheet bringing down the Royals because of their racism towards Machlish (aka Irish). the author tried to make it political and important but it just didn't play out very well, the instant and boring romance took priority in the story.
"Is this a dream?"
"I don't know. Let me kiss you util dawn, and I suppose we'll find out."
lastly, there is one scene where the romance gets more PG-13 and had me a bit shocked considering this is supposed to be YA, I would be upset if my kids at 12 or 13 were reading this and found out there's a detailed sex scene on page. YA should stay closed door, it for literal kids under 17!
**thank you Netgalley for an arc
Content Warnings
Minor: Cursing, Alcohol, and Sexual content