nancyflanagan's profile picture

nancyflanagan 's review for:

House Rules by Jodi Picoult
4.0

Picoult seems to be stuck in a formula: Kid with Desperate Condition changes Family Dynamic, Plus a Trial.

So why give it four stars? Because there's something compelling about Picoult's formula--you always want to know how the story turns out, and there are always a handful of interesting one-off characters lurking about: The 28-year old farrier-turned-lawyer. The detective who could have been Emma's boyfriend. The borderline Asperger's Dad. The social skills coach who doesn't have enough self-confidence to see that her "boyfriend" is a loser. And the most interesting character, Theo.

But really--Picoult should change it up a bit. Her earlier books, equally well written, went exploring more often. "Songs of the Humpback Whale," for example. Picoult feels paralyzed, since "My Sister's Keeper." She can do better.