sreddous's profile picture

sreddous 's review for:

4.75
funny hopeful lighthearted reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

What a MASTER CLASS in writing an "unreliable" first-person narrator. 

It is hard, as an adult author, to write dialogue that sounds realistically-enough like the way teens and young people talk. This month I've read a few books that IMO don't always do this very well. THIS book is astonishing in how accurate it is. My friends and I definitely, absolutely talked and thought like this. Even with the lens of "this book is on-purpose a very dramatic and over-the-top slice-of-life story" it's very easy IMO to get immersed in why Patch thinks and feels the way he does about things. That's what makes this book earn its 5-star rating to me. I can both see why he reaches the conclusions he does AND also grind my teeth waiting for him to fix his mistakes, and it's very satisfying to get both!

I think the ending was maybe a bit "not dramatic enough" which feels like a silly thing after the whole book was so over-the-top, but maybe that's actually a good thing and really shows how Patch can grow and can do a better job of realizing how his behavior affects other people.

Overall, this is a lot of fun. It's got some serious topics here and there but otherwise is a lighthearted take on a theater kid's attempts at socializing, communication, and romance, and, yeah, that's all  fun stuff to be dealing with in high school.