A review by natlren
Lady Macbeth by Ava Reid

adventurous dark fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.5

"Madness, of all things, is the most unforgivable in a woman."

Never in my life have I had to sleep on a book before sitting down to review it, but my thoughts towards Lady Macbeth are complicated and I needed the time to process how I felt about them. At its core, this is a Macbeth retelling, yes. The main players are still present and, in line with the original play, still scheming and murdering and betraying one another. But Ava Reid's Lady Macbeth, elusive in her power and a figure who I regarded as the real orchestrater of so many of the events in Macbeth, has been reduced to someone that I don't quite recognize in this novel.

When I originally think of Lady Macbeth, I think of power and ambition and madness. I also think of the infamous Lady Macbeth Syndrome, which has been an interest of mine as of late. I feel like it was definitely... a choice, I guess, to make Lady Macbeth a seventeen year old French girl named Roscille, and though I don't hate that direction, I believe that it changes the reader's relationship with this once manipulative, ambitious woman who turned her husband into the dagger in her hands, not vice versa.

But while I'm not entirely decided on my feelings to change Lady Macbeth from puppet master to accomplice, I can appreciate the feminist themes of this novel. Though they were a bit heavy handed and wildly repetitive, Lady Macbeth's journey towards agency and self-autonomy was enjoyable enough to read. I also enjoyed the decision to turn Lady Macbeth into a witch and have her uncovered eyes enchant men should they stare into them. I just felt that that particular trait was not used as much as I'd like it to be.

I think that this book also needed more space to simply be. At times, the pacing felt off and certain scenes incredibly rushed. I also can't say that I was a fan of the insta-love that happened between Roscille and another character, especially because there was no build up to it. Don't misunderstand though: some of the lines between Roscille and her love interest were the best in the novel, and I can appreciate the purpose of this love for what it was meant to do and the power it was supposed to help Roscille accept. I'm just, at my core, incredibly critical of relationships with no genuine direction.

Finally, my last issue with this novel lies with the infamous Macbeth, who, by the end, felt almost cartoonish in his villainy. Perhaps it's because Shakespeare's Macbeth, though undoubtedly a villain, is still a sympathetic character manipulated by forces outside of his control. Perhaps it's because I felt like Macbeth's absence shaped more of the narrative then his presence on page. Whatever it is, Ava Reid's decision to to cast him as a one-dimensional villain and disregard the complexities of his character to make him truly awful (and he is, truly, awful) towards his wife really clashes with the united force that was Macbeth and his Lady in the original play. But I digress.

What this book does really, truly succeed at, though, is atmosphere. Glammis is a bleak, wind-swept place and Macbeth's basement, especially, has Ava Reid's signature dose of locational horror. There's an undercurrent of dread that continues the build throughout the novel's progression, starting almost immediately from our opening scene. That, I think, was one of my favorite aspects of this novel and a real redeemer for me when I sat down to organize my (still very messy) thoughts.

Even by the end of this review, I'm still conflicted with my thoughts. Ava Reid has been my favorite author for years now, and I'm disappointed that this book was not an immediate five stars like the rest of their work has been. That said, you bet I still have this novel on preorder.


Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for providing a copy in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are my own. 
Expand filter menu Content Warnings