Scan barcode
A review by ambenicole418
Belladonna by Adalyn Grace
dark
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
An average YA gothic murder mystery story featuring the author’s poorly disguised kink for groomy/creepily paternalistic immortal boyfriends.
Honestly, it’s not the age difference that weirds me out about Signa x Death, it’s really the fact that Death has been watching and protecting Signa since she was a BABY, and for more than half of the book he acts as if he’s her father and not a potential love interest. I mean he does things like, killing off all of her family members because they didn’t treat Signa as kindly as he wanted them to, saving Blythe so Signa could go to Thorn Grove because he wanted her in a “safe and stable home”, he calls her “Little Bird” which frankly sounds like the nickname you would give to a child, and then when Signa refuses to let Death train her on how to use her powers he puts on his Dad voice and commands her to meet him at midnight for training. Ms. Adalyn creates this whole power imbalance between Death and Signa and spends the first half of the book setting Death up as if he’s going to be Signa’s father figure/mentor. It got to the point that by the time the tea party happens, I got whiplash because Death has a full 180 in his personality and starts acting like a jealous lover. The change is his demeanor was so drastic and came out of nowhere that I had to flip back through the book because I felt like I was missing something. How am I supposed to believe Death is her love interest when you write lines like:
“Why is it you are so polite to others? So demure and soft yet bullish when we speak? Ask me kindly, Signa.”
“Death spoke as though Signa were a child. As though she were a small, fragile thing that needed to be coddled.” (remind you Signa is 19 years old, so why is he talking to her as if she’s a child???)
It has to be either gaslighting or Ms. Adalyn just SET OUT to create a creepily paternalistic relationship between them because how are these lines said about the love interest?? It certainly didn’t help that the romance was incredibly inorganic, Death literally admitted that the only reason he’s interested in Signa at all is because she shares his powers and can’t be killed by his touch, and Death says things like,
“I have waited for you for a very long time, Signa.”
Like yeah Death, we know, you’ve been watching Signa since she was a baby and she’s 19 now, so you’ve been watching and waiting for about……….19 years for Signa to become legal 💀.
Outside of Signa being in a relationship with her father-boyfriend, the book is really just average. It reads like a lot of other YA books that are popular on social media. It’s not bad. The main mystery is just fairly predictable and nothing to write home about. So, the book was fine I just couldn’t vibe with Signa being in a relationship with this creepily paternalistic and groomy shadow.
Honestly, it’s not the age difference that weirds me out about Signa x Death, it’s really the fact that Death has been watching and protecting Signa since she was a BABY, and for more than half of the book he acts as if he’s her father and not a potential love interest. I mean he does things like, killing off all of her family members because they didn’t treat Signa as kindly as he wanted them to, saving Blythe so Signa could go to Thorn Grove because he wanted her in a “safe and stable home”, he calls her “Little Bird” which frankly sounds like the nickname you would give to a child, and then when Signa refuses to let Death train her on how to use her powers he puts on his Dad voice and commands her to meet him at midnight for training. Ms. Adalyn creates this whole power imbalance between Death and Signa and spends the first half of the book setting Death up as if he’s going to be Signa’s father figure/mentor. It got to the point that by the time the tea party happens, I got whiplash because Death has a full 180 in his personality and starts acting like a jealous lover. The change is his demeanor was so drastic and came out of nowhere that I had to flip back through the book because I felt like I was missing something. How am I supposed to believe Death is her love interest when you write lines like:
“Why is it you are so polite to others? So demure and soft yet bullish when we speak? Ask me kindly, Signa.”
“Death spoke as though Signa were a child. As though she were a small, fragile thing that needed to be coddled.” (remind you Signa is 19 years old, so why is he talking to her as if she’s a child???)
It has to be either gaslighting or Ms. Adalyn just SET OUT to create a creepily paternalistic relationship between them because how are these lines said about the love interest?? It certainly didn’t help that the romance was incredibly inorganic, Death literally admitted that the only reason he’s interested in Signa at all is because she shares his powers and can’t be killed by his touch, and Death says things like,
“I have waited for you for a very long time, Signa.”
Like yeah Death, we know, you’ve been watching Signa since she was a baby and she’s 19 now, so you’ve been watching and waiting for about……….19 years for Signa to become legal 💀.
Outside of Signa being in a relationship with her father-boyfriend, the book is really just average. It reads like a lot of other YA books that are popular on social media. It’s not bad. The main mystery is just fairly predictable and nothing to write home about. So, the book was fine I just couldn’t vibe with Signa being in a relationship with this creepily paternalistic and groomy shadow.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Death of parent, and Grief
Moderate: Sexual content and Vomit