A review by snerp_reads
Earthlings by Sayaka Murata

dark mysterious slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.75

The concept for this book was very interesting, and worth exploring, but I feel this book fell flat. 
I did enjoy the small tidbits of world-building around Natsuki's belief in Popinpobopia, and
how she used said beliefs to mask her coping mechanisms and responses to abuse as magical powers in her young mind.
 
I thought we would've gotten a longer narrative through her childhood,
but 40% into the book there was a pretty long time skip, which I felt threw off the pacing.
This would have been fine by itself, but the story seems to unravel too quickly and without satisfactory explanation
in the last quarter of the book.
Alongside those pacing issues, a lot of the heavier topics depicted seemed slightly ham-fisted in and included mainly for shock value, instead of for relevance or genuine exploration. There does seem to be an issue with the characters, especially Natsuki. The voice of her childhood self and her adult self are identical, in a way that both makes her sound too old as a child and too young and naive as an adult. This weird contradiction is prevalent from the start, and never goes away. The ending did not make sense or feel very thought out to me, and the few twists at the end didn't have much foreshadowing. 
However, I did find Natsuki and her husband's relationship interesting, and a refreshing change of pace from most written marriages.
The mechanic of framing Natsuki's vision of herself as an alien was also one of the main things I liked about this book.
I enjoyed the concept Murata created, and was drawn in to read more when she used it to explore Natsuki's feelings and reactions to the mistreatment of her by the adults around her, but I feel the book ultimately veered too hard into shock-value territory, and caused any potential messages or analysis to be flung out.
Expand filter menu Content Warnings