A review by moonpie
The Best American Mystery Stories 2018 by Louise Penny, Otto Penzler

3.0

I used to love The Best American collections, but hadn't read one in a while, and I don't think I've ever read the mystery flavor, so I was excited to go through this one. I'd say I thoroughly enjoyed about a quarter of the stories, didn't mind a third, and thought it was puzzling that the remaining stories were included, because they didn't seem great, and certainly not "best." I don't read a ton of mysteries, though, so my best-ometer might be out of whack.