Scan barcode
A review by astoryofpages
Uprooted by Naomi Novik
adventurous
dark
mysterious
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
This book was a pleasant surprise. I wasn't sure what to expect other than a story inspired by Slavic folklore (which I don't know very well, so I couldn't dwell on it too much). I was very startled by Naomi Novik's writing. I felt like I was reading a fairy tale. Look out, not a children's story, and that I want to clarify quickly. I saw the book classified in YA, but for me, this book is Adult, or maybe New Adult. I had a little trouble with some very described scenes (I don't want to know how the blood is spurting). So even if the story seems gentle and soft, be aware of that.
I appreciated the worldbuilding: even if I'd have preferred to have a map because, without one, I couldn't locate the kingdoms, cities and towns. The magic system is interesting, with this mystery around Jaga, who is, in fact, Baba Jaga. I would have liked to know a little more about wizards in general, like Alosha, I think, from whom we could have learned a lot.
The plot was a little radical at times. Writers often have this "weakness" of wanting to kill their characters all the time to solve the problem (sometimes, I found myself not understanding some reversals). Nevertheless, this whole idea of The Wood, which is almost a living and threatening entity, was all fascinating, and I think it was rather well. It's an element that wasn't put aside, and I loved the end, which remains slightly open. I liked how Agnieszka's adventure ends.
The characters were enjoyable. I loved Kasia and her journey, which is quite incredible. She is truly a role model, very courageous and believes in her values. Agnieszka left me a little more unmoved. I struggled to grasp her personality at first. She seemed a little empty to me. I think she does become someone at the very end, which is a bit sad since I would have liked it done earlier. As for the Dragon, just like the other wizards, he lacked details and depth. Wizards remain very superficial, sadly. I don't have much to say about relationships other than maybe I would have preferred there to be no romantic relationship (if it's love) because I think it comes kind of out of nowhere. Or to get just a glimpse of it at the very end, just a suggestion for readers who wanted to see one, while the others had nothing since they didn't want to see anything between these two characters.
I appreciated the worldbuilding: even if I'd have preferred to have a map because, without one, I couldn't locate the kingdoms, cities and towns. The magic system is interesting, with this mystery around Jaga, who is, in fact, Baba Jaga. I would have liked to know a little more about wizards in general, like Alosha, I think, from whom we could have learned a lot.
The plot was a little radical at times. Writers often have this "weakness" of wanting to kill their characters all the time to solve the problem (sometimes, I found myself not understanding some reversals). Nevertheless, this whole idea of The Wood, which is almost a living and threatening entity, was all fascinating, and I think it was rather well. It's an element that wasn't put aside, and I loved the end, which remains slightly open. I liked how Agnieszka's adventure ends.
The characters were enjoyable. I loved Kasia and her journey, which is quite incredible. She is truly a role model, very courageous and believes in her values. Agnieszka left me a little more unmoved. I struggled to grasp her personality at first. She seemed a little empty to me. I think she does become someone at the very end, which is a bit sad since I would have liked it done earlier. As for the Dragon, just like the other wizards, he lacked details and depth. Wizards remain very superficial, sadly. I don't have much to say about relationships other than maybe I would have preferred there to be no romantic relationship (if it's love) because I think it comes kind of out of nowhere. Or to get just a glimpse of it at the very end, just a suggestion for readers who wanted to see one, while the others had nothing since they didn't want to see anything between these two characters.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Misogyny, Violence, Sexual violence, Blood, and Mental illness