A review by depreydeprey
Sherlock: A Scandal in Belgravia Part 1 by Mark Gatiss, Steven Moffat

2.0

This is the first half of an manga nearly shot for shot adaptation of the best episode of the TV show Sherlock. I felt about this the same way I might about seeing a tribute band play instead of the real thing. While this is obviously a faithful adaption the life feels drained out of the story and as much bandwidth is devoted to how books can't properly be made into movies this book does a fine job showing how the reverse is also true.