A review by cepbreed
The Poppy War by R.F. Kuang

dark emotional tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.5

I'm still processing. To think that this book is a debut is insane to me. R. F. Kuang can do no wrong. I love her storytelling but I am so glad I started the Poppy War series after reading her two standalone novels. I fear the others would have disappointed me if they followed a read of this. 

The first half of the novel felt slow. I wasn't able to get into the storyline because it was so glaringly unoriginal. There, I said it. Sure, a tried and true plot is only tried and true because it works, but I picked up this book expecting more. It took weeks to find that more thanks to my modules and plain disinterest. Smack dab in the center of the book lies that gritty tonal shift that I could really sink my teeth into. I appreciate so much that Kuang is a historian because she never shied away from the brutality of war. The inspiration drawn from the atrocities committed by the Japanese made me sick to my stomach.
Venka, and the real women who were forced to become "comfort women" bring out a deep hatred for men within me.
That quality saved a novel that plateaued in the first half. I understand a world like this needs exposition and I also get that for that shift to take effect the beginning would have to be more tame in comparison (I'm struggling to find the right words here because I don't think "tame" correctly describes a girl
removing her own uterus
but alas). I can forget all of my grips with this book because any ending that makes me feel like this one did is deserving of innumerable praise. I balked when I turned the page and "Acknowledgements" stared back at me. I'm simultaneously thirsty for more and unbelieving that a book such as this one should or could be followed up. In a way, even with the loose ends in the plot, I think I would be content if the story just ended here. I thank Kuang for never being afraid to
kill off main characters, but at the same time, nearly all of the original cast is gone. New characters won't endear themselves to me in the same way the academy kids did. In the Tiktoks I sometimes get about this book people seem to have endless praise for Nezha so maybe he isn't dead? But that's lowkey overkill because c'mon, no way one teenage boy can miraculously dodge paralysis and death consecutively. Then again it is mentioned he's hiding something, maybe he's got like healing powers thanks to his family god or something.
The power system of this universe is convoluted in the best way. However, I can't entirely wrap my head around it so the confusion is getting to me. 

In the wake of the new Avatar live-action series I hope this never gets greenlit for any sort of on-screen adaptation. Not to deprive Kuang of her bag, but there's just no way in hell any show or movie would do this book justice. If they do make one though trust I will be watching the second it comes out. 

Song:
  • Lipstick on the Glass - Wolf Alice
Expand filter menu Content Warnings