Scan barcode
A review by periwinkle_flora
The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.25
The novel felt like a fast-medium paced, simple indie film.
I agree with 2 things 2 others have said. The book is conversational and the book didn't feel like a warm hug.
but rather... a simple, light, and casual read.
Mika Moon has a rough life. Her family she finds, Ian, Ken, Lucie, Jamie, and the sisters, had rough lives too. Personality and backgrounds appear frequently throughout the chats between the cast.
We read what's happening to the characters. but we don't really feel what's happening to the characters.
We are told what's happened in their pasts, but we don't get transferred back in time, to see what it was like.
Personally, I would've preferred if the book showcased more emotional depth to make me feel something… versus briefly glowing over key relationships that make them who they are.
Another aspect that felt less cosy were the swearing – which in any other book *works*, but not here – and the shift in the main romance/ conflict towards the end.
Would I read it again? Likely not. Did it keep me engaged? Yes.
Overall:
A strong 3. (3|5).
I agree with 2 things 2 others have said. The book is conversational and the book didn't feel like a warm hug.
but rather... a simple, light, and casual read.
Mika Moon has a rough life. Her family she finds, Ian, Ken, Lucie, Jamie, and the sisters, had rough lives too. Personality and backgrounds appear frequently throughout the chats between the cast.
We read what's happening to the characters. but we don't really feel what's happening to the characters.
We are told what's happened in their pasts, but we don't get transferred back in time, to see what it was like.
Personally, I would've preferred if the book showcased more emotional depth to make me feel something… versus briefly glowing over key relationships that make them who they are.
Another aspect that felt less cosy were the swearing – which in any other book *works*, but not here – and the shift in the main romance/ conflict towards the end.
Would I read it again? Likely not. Did it keep me engaged? Yes.
Overall:
A strong 3. (3|5).
Content Warnings
Moderate: Cursing
Minor: Grief, Sexual content, and Physical abuse